All posts by ypennhsd

Cruel Summer Deconstructed – Sample Report

Cruel Summer Deconstructed
Cruel Summer Deconstructed

Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift's "Cruel Summer" stands as a testament to the resilience of great song, proving that even adverse circumstances cannot suppress its eventual success. Originally featured on Swift’s 2019 album, Lover, and slated for single release in 2020, the trajectory of "Cruel Summer" was altered due to the global onset of the Covid-19 pandemic. This unforeseen event coincided with Swift's artistic shift toward a more organic and acoustic folk-leaning direction, as evidenced by her acclaimed albums folklore and evermore.

Since then, Swift began embracing her pop side once again, both with her Taylor’s Version reissues and the 2022 electropop/synthpop heavy, retro 1980s-tinged album, Midnights. These releases collectively paved the way for the resurgence of "Cruel Summer,” which gained further visibility as the sophomore song in her Eras Tour set list, resulting in increased traction on streaming platforms. With fan interest high, the song was finally, and strategically, released as a single in the summer of 2023 (June), subsequently hitting the top 10 of the Billboard Hot 100 in July.

Written by Swift, Jack Antonoff and St. Vincent, “Cruel Summer” embodies the hallmark qualities of a chart-topping pop hit. Vocally, the song adheres to the K.I.S.S. ME principle (keep it simple, singable and memorable), possesses expert vocal production and features a captivating vocal performance from Swift. Adding to the song’s catchiness are its three distinct vocal hooks: a recurring vocoder-infused "yeah” that is featured at three strategic points in the song, the “down below” song title hook and accompanying nonsense vocal in the chorus, and the shouted vocals in the bridge that struck Olivia Rodrigo to such a degree that she incorporated the bridge’s essence in her 2021 hit, “déjà vu,” resulting in additional writing credits.

Structurally, "Cruel Summer" seamlessly blends contemporary pop trends with discernible deviations that underscore its uniqueness. Notable among these differentiating qualities is the presence of two bridges, a departure from the conventional single bridge format, and its significantly shorter-than-average verses, which helped put the song in line with mainstream music’s gravitation towards shorter runtimes.

The expertly crafted, retro-tinged, synth-heavy instrumental arrangement creates a highly engaging musical backdrop that keeps the listener engaged from start to finish and complements the narrative. Furthermore, the song imparts a sense of familiarity to the listener through its incorporation of electropop/synthpop elements and a nostalgic touch of the retro 1980s within its sonic palette. These musical nuances align with micro trends that played a role in shaping notable Hot 100 Top 10 hits both in 2019 and 2023.

"Cruel Summer" by Taylor Swift stands as a testament to the timeless power of exceptional music. Its journey from initial creation to eventual prominence encapsulates the fusion of strategic timing, musical prowess, and an unswerving connection with a devoted audience.

Since its release, “Cruel Summer” has attained global charting success. In the US, it peaked at #1 in the Billboard Hot 100 and topped the Mainstream Top 40 and Adult Top 40 charts. Abroad, it cracked the top 10 on numerous charts, hitting the top spot in Canada, the Philippines and Singapore.

At-A-Glance


Artist: Taylor Swift
Song: "Cruel Summer"
Songwriters: Jack Antonoff, St. Vincent, Taylor Swift
Producers: Jack Antonoff, Taylor Swift
Mastering Engineer: Randy Merrill
Mixer: Serban Ghenea
Record Label: Republic
Primary Genre: Pop
Influences: Retro (1980s), Electropop/Synthpop
Length: 2:55
Form: I-A-PC-B-T-A-PC-B-C-B-C-O
Key: A Major
Tempo: 85 BPM
First Chorus: 0:28 / 16% of the way into the song
Intro Length: 0:05
Electronic vs. Acoustic Instrumentation: Primarily Electronic
Prominent Instruments: Bass (Synth), Drums/Percussion (Primarily Electronic), Synth (Non-Bass)
Primary Lyrical Theme: Love/Relationships
Title Appearances: "Cruel Summer" appears six times in the song

"Cruel Summer" Section Abbreviation Key
I = Intro | A = Verse | PC = Pre-Chorus | B = Chorus | C = Bridge
“D” = Departure | T = Turnaround | O = Outro
Music notation and lyric excerpts are reproduced here under Fair Use terms, for the purposes of commentary and criticism.

Overview, Highlights & Takeaways


Hooks

At the heart of “Cruel Summer” are its uniquely delivered and strategically placed vocal hooks that make it an irresistible earworm of a song that keeps the listener engaged from start to finish.

Vocoder Hooks

The intro, outro and turnaround feature a simple, monotone, quarter-note-driven vocoder-processed “yeah” hook that serves a multitude of purposes:

  • It functions as a unique, instantly recognizable calling card for the song.
  • It hooks the listener in on a profound level in the intro.
  • It “resets” the song and provides and engaging transition into verse 2 following the first intro – verse – pre-chorus – chorus progression.
  • It concludes the song on a familiar and catchy note in the outro. 

In addition, both verse sections feature catchy, vocoder-processed background vocal “nano” hooks that create a catchy call and response flow with Swift’s lead. Their inclusion also has a lyrical implication, as they cleverly voice Swift’s internal conflicted desire for her love interest.

Paired Hooks: Nonsensical Hook and Song Title Hook

Each stanza of the chorus concludes with the “ooh, woah-oh” nonsense hook followed by the “it’s a cruel summer” summative song title hook. Both feature the same melismatic melody, which serves heighten their memorability while showcasing Swift’s vocal chops. In addition, the melismatic quality of the nonsense hook cleverly communicates the emotion Swift feels without the need to outright state it (i.e., a “show don’t tell” approach). 

Shouted Hooks

The bridge uniquely features two standout shouted vocal hooks that are primely placed at the end each stanza: “I don’t wanna keep secrets just to keep you,” and the even more emotionally riveting, “I love you ain’t that the worst thing you ever heard.” The directness of the melody along with the sung/shouted hybrid delivery bolsters each statement’s impact while creating unique standout moments in the scope of the song.

Furthermore, a testament to the bridge’s overall strength is its interpolation in Olivia Rodrigo’s hit, “déjà vu,” which resulted in Swift, Antonoff and St. Vincent all getting writing credits.
 

Structure: Overview

Genres & Influences: Overview

"Cruel Summer" features a combination of pop, electropop/synthpop and retro 1980s influences that are put into effect by the qualities of the vocals, instruments, lyrics, and the overall production.

Key

X: The influence appears prominently within the stanza and/or section
x: The influence appears 

Instrumentation & Arrangement: Overview

Energy: Overview

S.I.A. (Section Impact Accentuator) Key

Downward Red S.I.A.: The full accompaniment is removed from the mix, resulting in a brief reduction in energy
Downward Yellow S.I.A.: A part of the accompaniment is removed from the mix, resulting in a brief reduction in energy
Upward Green S.I.A.: The accompaniment creates a brief rise in energy

Harmony: Overview

“Cruel Summer” features three core progressions, each with subtle variations.

Progression 1

Progression 1: Variation 1 (Intro)

A

Progression 2

Progression 2: Variation 1 (Verses)

D – E – C#m – F#m

Progression 2: Variation 2 (Pre-Choruses)

D – E – C#m – F#m – D – E

Progression 3

Progression 3: Variation 1 (Choruses)

A – C#m – F#m – D

Progression 3: Variation 2 (Bridges)

A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D – A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D – N.C.

Vocal Production: Overview

Lead Vocal Gender

“Cruel Summer” features a solo female lead vocal from Taylor Swift. In the first half of 2023, solo male leads were by far most common among non-hip hop hits at half of all songs, followed distantly by solo female leads at just 17%.

Lead Vocal Gender in the Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2018 – Q2 2023

Lead Vocal Delivery

“Cruel Summer” features an almost entirely sung vocal delivery, save for a few sung/shouted hybrid deliveries in the bridge sections. Despite exclusively sung deliveries continuing to be by far most common among non-hip hop hits, they have been in decline since 2020 while sung/rapped combo deliveries have been on the rise.

Lead Vocal Delivery in the Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2018 – Q2 2023

Lead Vocal Delivery 2018-2022

Background Vocals

Complementing Swift’s lead are an array of background vocals including unison doubles, octave doubles, above and below the lead harmonies, independent of the lead adlibs, and sustained vocal pads. Together, they serve to heighten interest throughout the song and call attention to key lyrics.

Effects & Processing

“Cruel Summer” features common hit song vocal processing, including reverb, compression, and subtle autotune to heighten the effectiveness of the vocal performance. In addition, a vocoder is used in both a lead and background capacity to provide vocal texture variation and create one of the song’s notable hooks.

Vocal Production Visualization Key

Lead: Female (Taylor Swift): Taylor Swift’s lead vocal
BGV 1: Female (Unison Double): Background vocal doubles in unison with the lead
BGV 2: Female (High Octave Double): Background vocal doubles an octave above the lead
BGV 3: Female (Low Octave Double): Background vocal doubles an octave below the lead
BGV 4: Female (Lead Harmony) (Above): Background vocals that harmonize with the lead on different pitches above the melody
BGV 5: Female (Lead Harmony) (Below): Background vocals that harmonize with the lead on different pitches below the melody
BGV 6: Female (Adlibs): Background vocals featured independently from the lead
BGV 7: Female (BGV Pad): Multiple background vocals stacked and sustained to create a pad-like effect
Vocoder: Vocoder vocal hook independent from all vocals, functions in a background and lead capacity

S: Sung
SH: Shouted
BGV: Background vocals

Vocal Delivery Arrangement Overview

Vocal Melody: Overview

Sectional Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

INTRO & OUTRO

VERSE 1

VERSE 2

PRE-CHORUSES

CHORUSES

BRIDGES

Sectional Melodic Pattern: At-A-Glance

INTRO & OUTRO

VERSE 1

VERSE 2

PRE-CHORUSES

CHORUSES

BRIDGES

Rhymes: Overview

“Cruel Summer” features an abundance of expertly crafted rhymes and other lyrical connection accentuators that bolsters the song’s ability to connect and resonate. Among them are logically unfolding end-of-line rhyme schemes and a plethora of strategically placed internal rhymes, double rhymes, alliterations, lyrical repetitions, cross-section commonalities and unique pronunciations to make rhymes happen where they otherwise wouldn’t.

Key

A, B & C: End-of-line rhymes
X: Non-rhymes
Lyric/Syllable: The primary rhyme at the end of each line
Underline: Repetitive lyrics
Colors and rhyme schemes are unique to each section

*For simplicity of analysis, note that only lyrics connected by both rhyme and another notable characteristic (i.e., proximity, placement, melodic connection, etc.) are shown in each table. Lyrics that rhyme but are otherwise unconnected are not noted.

Narrative: Overview

“Cruel Summer” is a love/relationships-themed song about a protagonist (Taylor Swift) and her intense desire for a bad boy love interest that she knows will likely not end well. The song makes great use of the A.I.D.E. principle (action, imagery, detail devices, emotion) to convey the story in a compelling manner, while the abundance of clever, metaphorical lyricism engages the listener on a deep level. However, the listener is always able to grasp what it’s all about, which is a testament to Swift’s masterful lyric-writing skills.

In addition, the lyricism and overarching story creates intrigue as to which boyfriend Taylor Swift is singing about and also cleverly relates to other songs within her body of work. An example is the standout lyric, “devils roll the dice, angels roll their eyes,” which appears on a board game in Swift’s “Lover” music video. While this reference will likely go unnoticed by the casual listener, for diehard Swift fans it’s an easter egg of a find.

INTRO & OUTRO

VERSE 1

PRE-CHORUS 1

CHORUS

VERSE 2

PRE-CHORUS 2

BRIDGE 1

Song Structure


Overview

"Cruel Summer" possesses structural qualities that are both in line with, and depart from, recent Hot 100 Top 10 non-hip hop trends. Notable commonalities include its easy-to-follow form, the inclusion of two verses and three choruses, beginning with an intro and concluding with an outro, and running on the shorter end of the spectrum, among others.

However, the song also goes against the grain in certain key areas as well. Two of the most notable are the inclusion of two bridge “D” (departure) sections as opposed to one, and its significantly shorter-than-average verses.

Song Sections

"Cruel Summer" contains 12 sections in its framework:

  • One intro section
  • Two verse sections
  • Two pre-chorus sections
  • Three chorus sections
  • One turnaround section
  • Two bridge sections
  • One outro section

Structural Anomalies

Two bridge "D" (Departure) sections

While the inclusion of a “D” (departure) section is highly common in non-hip hop hits, with the bridge being most popular, the inclusion of two bridge “D” sections is not. "Cruel Summer" features two lyrically and melodically similar bridges following choruses 2 and 3. The first provides a departure and development against the two verse – pre-chorus – chorus progressions that precede it, while the second reinforces the catchy section as the song heads into the bookending outro.

Form

Cruel Summer Form

Time and Percent into the Song When Sections Occur

"Cruel Summer"

Cruel Summer Time and Percent

Core A-B-A-B-D-B Form in Hot 100 Top 10 Hits (Q3 2022 – Q2 2023)

"Cruel Summer’s" core sections (verse, chorus and first bridge) occur slightly to moderately earlier than the Hot 100 Top 10 average. This is mainly due to its notably shorter-than-average verse lengths (see below for details).

Song & Section Length

Song Length

"Cruel Summer" clocks in at 2:55, 17 seconds shorter than the mid-year 2023 average of 3:12. Over the past five years, the under three-minute range has generally been rising in popularity, peaking at 37% of non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits in 2022 before dropping slightly to one-third in the first half of 2023.

Song Length Ranges of Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2018 – Q2 2023

Cruel Summer Song Length Range

Section Length

"Cruel Summer’s" sections range from 1 to 9 bars in length. The turnaround and bookending intro and outro are the shortest sections in the song, landing at 1 and 2 bars, respectively. The pre-choruses and verses follow at 4 bars, the choruses and second bridge at 8 bars, and the first bridge clocking in the longest at 9 bars, with the extra bar serving as a “Last Chorus Super S.I.A. (Section Impact Accentuator)” technique.

Note that "Cruel Summer’s" section runtimes are relatively in line with non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 averages in the first half of 2023 save for the verses and outro, which clock in at 15 seconds and 16 seconds shorter, respectively. 

Cruel Summer Section Lengths

*Note: Section lengths may be rounded.

Total Section Breakdown

*Note that numbers may be rounded, resulting in slightly more or less than 100% of the song’s total composition

As is commonly the case with hit songs, the greatest amount of time in "Cruel Summer" is spent in the chorus, comprising 39% of its total composition. Far less common, however, is having the bridges follow as opposed to the verses, comprising 27% and 13%, respectively. Following the pre-choruses, which also comprise 13%, the intro and outro round things out with just 3% of the total song each.

In terms of trends, "Cruel Summer" allocates notably more time to the bridge (mainly due to there being two as opposed to one) and notably less time to the verse and outro. The other sections are relatively in line with Top 10 averages (within 5% or less).

"Cruel Summer" / Q3 2022 – Q2 2023 Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Average Time Allocation

  • Intro: 3% / 7%
  • Verse: 13% / 29%
  • Pre-Chorus: 13% / 14%
  • Chorus: 39% / 34%
  • Bridge: 27% / 9%
  • Outro: 3% / 11%

Tempo and Key

Tempo

"Cruel Summer" sits at 85 BPM, 17 BPM slower than the mid-year 2023 non-hip hop average of 102 BPM. Other notable, diverse recent hits that fall into 80-89 tempo range include un x100to and the #1s Bad Habit and Kill Bill.

Tempo Range in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2018 – Q2 2023 (Top 5)

Cruel Summer Tempo Range

Key

"Cruel Summer" is in the key of A major. Major tonalities in non-hip hop songs have been in the majority since 2019, accounting for 57% in the first half of 2023.

Major vs. Minor Keys in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2018 – Q2 2023

Cruel Summer Key

Hooks


At the heart of “Cruel Summer” are its uniquely delivered and strategically placed vocal hooks that make it an irresistible earworm of a song that keeps the listener engaged from start to finish.

Vocal Hooks

Vocoder Hooks
The intro, outro and turnaround feature a simple, monotone, quarter-note-driven vocoder-processed “yeah” hook that serves a multitude of purposes:

  • It functions as a unique, instantly recognizable calling card for the song.
  • It hooks the listener in on a profound level in the intro.
  • It “resets” the song and provides and engaging transition into verse 2 following the first intro – verse – pre-chorus – chorus progression.
  • It concludes the song on a familiar and catchy note in the outro. 

In addition, both verse sections feature catchy, vocoder-processed background vocal “nano” hooks that create a catchy call and response flow with Swift’s lead. Their inclusion also has a lyrical implication, as they cleverly voice Swift’s internal conflicted desire for her love interest.


Paired Hooks: Nonsensical Hook and Song Title Hook
Each stanza of the chorus concludes with the “ooh, woah-oh” nonsense hook followed by the “it’s a cruel summer” summative song title hook. Both feature the same melismatic melody, which serves heighten their memorability while showcasing Swift’s vocal chops. In addition, the melismatic quality of the nonsense hook cleverly communicates the emotion Swift feels without the need to outright state it (i.e., a “show don’t tell” approach).

Shouted Hooks
The bridge uniquely features two standout shouted vocal hooks that are primely placed at the end each stanza: “I don’t wanna keep secrets just to keep you,” and the even more emotionally riveting, “I love you ain’t that the worst thing you ever heard.” The directness of the melody along with the sung/shouted hybrid delivery bolsters each statement’s impact while creating unique standout moments in the scope of the song.

Furthermore, a testament to the bridge’s overall strength is its interpolation in Olivia Rodrigo’s hit, “déjà vu,” which resulted in Swift, Antonoff and St. Vincent all getting writing credits.

Genres & Influences


Genre & Influence Blend

Key

X: The influence appears prominently within the stanza and/or section
x: The influence appears minimally within the stanza and/or section
Cruel Summer Genres and Influences Table

"Cruel Summer" features a combination of pop, electropop/synthpop and retro 1980s influences that are put into effect by the qualities of the vocals, instruments, lyrics, and the overall production.

The song’s main overarching influence, and primary genre, is pop. Notable pop elements include its catchy K.I.S.S. ME (Keep It Simple, Singable and Memorable) melodies and hooks, familiar pop structure, relatable love/relationships-themed subject matter, and polished production, to name a few.

In addition, "Cruel Summer" possesses a strong electropop/synthpop influence, which is put into effect by its heavy use of synths. Some of these synths possess a classic timbre, which along with the mechanical synth bass pattern and use of vocoder provides the song with an underlying early-to-mid retro-1980s vibe. 

Blending In & Standing Out in the Hot 100 Top 10

"Cruel Summer’s" expert balance of pop, electropop/synthpop and retro 1980s influences enabled it to both blend in and stand out in the Hot 100 Top 10. While pop in general has been a constant influence in essentially all non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits over the years, electropop/synthpop and retro 1980s influences are more micro trends that rise and fall in popularity.

Electropop/synthpop, while present in nearly two-thirds of songs in 2018, plummeted to around one-fifth of songs by the end of 2020, before rising again to just over one-third of songs in 2022 and continuing into the first half of 2023. In addition to "Cruel Summer," recent representatives include the #1s "As It Was" (Harry Styles), "Like Crazy" (Jimin), and Taylor Swift’s other recent megahit, "Anti-Hero."

Retro 1980s is even more niche, generally accounting for one-fifth of songs or less over the past decade save for spikes in 2015 (25% of songs) and 2022 (31% of songs). However, save for 2020, where the 1970s rose in popularity, the 1980s has consistently been the most popular decade among retro-tinged hits. Other recent representatives include the aforementioned "Anti-Hero," "As It Was" and "Like Crazy," and the Justin Bieber and The Kid LAROI’s #1 smash, "Stay."

Cruel Summer was also primed for success in 2020, when it was originally slated for release as a single but was put on the backburner due to the emerging Covid-19 epidemic. In the year prior, electropop/synthpop was peaking at just over two-thirds of songs, and retro 1980s, while far less popular at just 13%, was present in notable hits such as "Bad At Love" (Halsey), "Boo’d Up" (Ella Mai), "Never Be The Same" (Camila Cabello) and "Youngblood" (5 Seconds Of Summer).

Influences in the Hot 100 Top 10: 2018 – Q2 2023 (Outside the Hip Hop/Rap Primary Genre)

Key
Blue: Pop Green: Electropop/Synthpop | Red: Retro (1980s)

Energy & Dynamics


Energy Arrangement

S.I.A. (Section Impact Accentuator) Key

Downward Red S.I.A.: The full accompaniment is removed from the mix, resulting in a brief reduction in energy
Downward Yellow S.I.A.: A part of the accompaniment is removed from the mix, resulting in a brief reduction in energy
Upward Green S.I.A.: The accompaniment creates a brief rise in energy

Cruel Summer Energy Graph

Loudness

“Cruel Summer’s” loudness levels generally match the song’s three energy “waves,” progressing from low to high across each sectional progression. Levels range from -16.5 in the outro (quietest) to -7.5 in the chorus “hook centers” and climactic second bridge (loudest). Note that the higher loudness levels in these song-defining sections allows them to further stand out, connect and bolster the listener’s emotional connection with the song.

Cruel Summer LUFS Graph
Cruel Summer Full Waveform

Energy: Section-By-Section

Wave 1: Intro (I) – Chorus 1 (B1)

Intro (I)
In the same vein as many hit songs, “Cruel Summer’s” intro features one of the lowest energy levels in the song, which provides room for growth in subsequent sections. This is due to the sparseness of the arrangement, which consists solely of vocoder, low-octave synth bass, kick, and snare.

Note that in lieu of density, these elements establish the groove right from the get-go, providing a rhythmic pulse that carries over into the subsequent verse.

Verse 1 (A1)
Following the sparse intro, the verse kicks energy up a notch with the introduction of Swift’s lead vocal, as well as additional drum layers on the backbeat and a dark synth pad. In bar 3, a pulsing synth and electric guitar are added to the mix, heightening tension leading into the ensuing pre-chorus.

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Waveform

Pre-Chorus 1 (PC1)
The pre-chorus slightly bumps up energy over the verse, most notably in the second half of the section. Providing this rise is the more animated and impassioned quality of Swift’s vocal delivery, the tension-heightening, pulsing synth and electric guitar becoming a bit more prominent in the mix, and the focus on the tense five (V) chord leading into the chorus. 

Cruel Summer Pre Chorus 1 Waveform

S.I.A. #1

The song’s first S.I.A. (section impact accentuator) subtly bolsters the arrival of the first chorus. It’s put into effect through a subtle white noise riser on the last beat of the pre-chorus, followed by a prominent crash and hi hat roll punctuation on the downbeat of the chorus.

Chorus 1 (B1)
Following the tension-heightening pre-chorus, chorus 1 thrusts the song’s energy to its first peak, providing the listener with the first of three energy “payoffs.” This is a result of both instrumental and vocal developments, including the dense “wall” of synth and drum layers, Swift’s highly impassioned vocal delivery, and the additional lead and background vocal layers.

Note that big, high-energy first choruses like this have become somewhat of a rarity in the Hot 100 Top 10 compared to years past, evident in hits such Kelly Clarkson’s “Stronger” (2011), Miley Cyrus’s “Wrecking Ball” (2013), and Sia’s “Chandelier” (2014), to name a few. However, here it makes sense as it effectively supports the sentiment of the lyrics to create effective prosody and bolster’s the listener’s emotional connection with the song.  

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Waveform

Wave 2: Turnaround (T) – Chorus 2 (B2)

Turnaround (T)
Following the high energy first chorus, the turnaround notably brings the song’s energy back down at the beginning of “wave 2.” This is due to a reversion to the sparse intro arrangement, which is now processed with copious reverb, making it sound thinner and more distant in comparison. This dramatic shift serves to engage the listener at a heightened level following four consecutive sections of energy growth, and provide room for the song to build in subsequent sections.

Cruel Summer Turnaround Waveform

Verse 2 (A2)
Following the brief, low energy turnaround, verse 2 kicks the song’s energy back up with a denser, more present arrangement. While the section features highly similar qualities as its verse 1 counterpart, it uniquely adds new elements including prominent brass synth stabs and high, lead-harmonizing background vocals, which provide verse 2 with a slightly higher energy level in comparison. 

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Waveform

Pre-Chorus 2 (PC2)
Similar to the relationship between verses, pre-chorus 2 features a slightly higher energy level compared to its pre-chorus 1 counterpart. This is mainly due to the inclusion of the brass synth stabs, which weren’t featured the first time around. 

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 2 Waveform

S.I.A. #2

The last two beats of pre-chorus 2 employ a partial accompaniment pull S.I.A., removing the main drum groove from the mix, along with the addition of a white noise and reverse synth riser. Together, they notably heighten tension and anticipation leading into the second chorus, which is marked by the familiar crash and hi hat roll on the chorus’ downbeat.

Chorus 2 (B2)
Following the pronounced S.I.A. at the end of pre-chorus 2, chorus 2 hits with increased perceived impact and energy compared to the first time around due to the more notable contrast between S.I.A.s. However, as a whole, the second chorus’ energy is largely on par with chorus 1 due to their similar arrangements, save for a subtle bump in stanza 2 due to the additional vocal layers and the addition of the bright synth arpeggio. This takes the song’s energy to its second peak. 

Cruel Summer Chorus 2 Waveform

Wave 3: Bridge 1 (C1) – Outro (O)

Bridge 1 (C1)
Following the energy peak in chorus 2, the bridge 1 “D” section begins “wave 3” with a slight reduction in energy in its first stanza mainly due to the less dense instrumental and vocal arrangements. However, this is offset by a rise in rhythmic energy, put into effect by the driving qualities of the pronounced synth arpeggio, drums and Swift’s lead vocal, along with the iconic shouted/sung hybrid vocal at the end.

Stanza 2 then follows with a slightly higher energy, put into effect by the addition of a background vocal pad along with swelling synths, drum fill and shouted/sung vocals at the end that culminate in the “Last Chorus Super S.I.A.” technique leading into chorus 3 (see below for details).

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Waveform

S.I.A. #3

Following the engagement-heightening synth swells, drum fill and shouted vocals toward the end of the bridge, an extra bar is uniquely tacked on that removes all the instrumental elements from the mix, leaving only Swift’s shouted/sung hybrid lead vocal. This unexpected moment is what Hit Songs Deconstructed calls the “Last Chorus Super S.I.A.” technique, which serves to notably heighten engagement leading into the final climactic chorus in the song.

Furthermore, note that this brief lull was well warranted and highly important considering that there are no other sectional energy lulls in “wave 3” save for the outro (note that the most common place to bring down a song’s energy is in all, or most of, a “D” section such as a bridge). Albeit brief, without it, the listener would remain in sustained moderate to high energy for numerous sections, reducing the impact of the last chorus and potentially resulting in decreased engagement.

Chorus 3 (B3)
Chorus 3 hits with the greatest impact of all the choruses following the full accompaniment pull “Last Chorus Super S.I.A.” (note that the impact of each subsequent chorus has gotten more pronounced as the song progressed). Stanza 1 reprises the dense chorus 2, stanza 2 instrumental arrangement, while stanza 2 increases energy with additional background vocal layers. 

Cruel Summer Chorus 3 Waveform

S.I.A. #4

In between the third chorus and second bridge, a dark electronic hi hat provides a brief fill that provides separation between sections of similar accompaniment, heightening the listener’s engagement.

Bridge 2 (C2)
Bridge 2 takes the song’s energy to its grand peak. It does so by combining the dense chorus accompaniment with the driving bridge 1 vocals and shouted/sung punctuations, along with the forward motion of additional hi hat layers. The section culminates in a swell similar to that at the end of bridge 1, taking intensity and excitement to a climax before heading into the ensuing outro. 

Cruel Summer Bridge 2 Waveform

S.I.A. #5

In between bridge stanzas, the bright electronic hi hat provides a brief fill that serves to subtly provide separation between stanzas and heighten the listener’s engagement.

Outro (O)
Following the song’s energy peak in the second bridge, the outro winds the song down with a notable drop in energy through a reversion to the thinned-out arrangement that defines the intro and turnaround. 

Cruel Summer Outro Waveform

Instrumental Arrangement


Cruel Summer Logic Arrangement

Primary Instruments

Drums/Percussion

Kick (Electronic)
The electronic kick drum is introduced in the intro and drives the groove forward for the duration of the song. It is processed with notable compression to create a punchy timbre that cuts through the mix.

Bright Snare (Electronic)
The bright electronic snare possesses a thin, dry timbre and provides a cohesive backbeat thread throughout the entire song.

Gritty Snare (Electronic)
The gritty electronic snare is layered in with the bright snare in all sections save for the intro and outro. It possesses a bit-crushed distorted timbre and is treated with reverb.

Snare Rimshot (Electronic)
The electronic snare rimshot is initially heard in verse 1 and is present in every subsequent section save for the turnaround. It punctuates the backbeat with a unique, metallic, pitched timbre that stands out in the mix.

Reverberant Claps (Electronic)
The electronic claps are heard in the choruses and bridge 2. Their reverberant, dark timbre contrasts the otherwise brighter and dryer backbeat and contributes to the sections’ dense, climactic arrangements.

Bright Closed Hi Hat (Electronic)
The bright electronic closed hi hat is heard exclusively in the chorus and bridge sections. In each chorus, it provides a subtle roll punctuation to the beginning of each stanza, while in the bridge sections its role is more notable, contributing to the groove throughout. It features a bright, thin timbre, is panned slightly to the right and is featured at a low level in the mix.

Dark Closed Hi Hat (Electronic)
The dark electronic closed hi hat provides a fill between stanzas 1 and 2 of bridge 2 and features a dark, gritty timbre.

Closed Hi Hat (Acoustic)
The acoustic closed hi hat is featured solely in the bridge sections. It provides further rhythmic motion to the section, blending with the closed electronic hi hat.

Open Hi Hat (Acoustic)
The acoustic open hi hat is featured solely in the bridge sections, possessing a gritty timbre identical to its closed counterpart. It punctuates the “and” of beat 1, subtly heightening interest of each section’s rhythm.

Crash (Acoustic)
The acoustic crash is heard punctuating the downbeat of each stanza in the choruses and second bridge at a relatively low level in the mix. 

Bass

Low-Octave Staccato Synth Bass
The low-octave staccato synth bass is initially heard in the intro and appears in every subsequent section save for the choruses and bridges. It possesses a saw-wave timbre that is reminiscent of commonly heard Moog synth basses from the 1980s and plays a steady, mechanical sixteenth-note-driven rhythm, also in line with the 1980s.

High-Octave Staccato Synth Bass
The high-octave staccato synth bass is heard in the chorus and bridge sections. It features a filtered saw-wave timbre that effectively balances a strong articulation with an unobtrusive tone, providing an underlying mid-range synth pulse to the arrangement.

Sub Bass Synth
The sub bass synth is featured in the chorus and bridge sections, providing a sustained, sine wave foundation to the low end of the mix.

Synths

Vocoder (Instrumental)
Vocoder serves in more of an instrumental, textural capacity in the choruses and second bridge compared to its vocal hook focus in the intro, turnaround and outro.

Dark Synth Pad
The dark synth pad is initially heard in the first verse, and appears in every subsequent section save for the turnaround, second verse and pre-chorus, and outro. It possesses a filtered, retro-tinged timbre and provides subtle rhythmic and harmonic motion underneath the groove.

Dark Synth Pad (Filtered)
A low-level, heavily-filtered version of the dark synth pad appears in the second verse and pre-chorus.

Pulsing Synth
The pulsing synth is heard in the verses and pre-choruses. It performs a sixteenth-note pattern and possesses a bright timbre that gradually increases in volume leading into first and second choruses.

Bright Synth Pad
The bright synth pad is heard in the choruses and second bridge. It provides further harmonic support with a notably high-end focused, digital, resonant timbre that contrasts from the warm, rich sounds of the brass and dark pads.

Brass Synth Pad
The brass synth pad appears in the chorus and bridge sections. It features a saw wave-timbre reminiscent of a Roland Juno brass patch that further fills out the dense synth-driven arrangement.

Brass Synth Stabs
The brass synth stabs appear solely in the second verse and pre-chorus sections. They are featured prominently in the mix, providing harmonic support while bolstering the retro 1980s influence with a timbre also reminiscent of a Roland Juno.

Bright Synth Arpeggio
The bright synth arpeggio is initially heard in the second stanza of chorus 2 and is featured in every subsequent section save for the outro. It features a bright, percussive timbre and provides further rhythmic motion within the dense arrangement. It is panned across the stereo field and is at a low level in the mix, becoming most audible when reaching higher-register notes in sparser sections.

High Synth Drone
The high synth drone pad provides a sustained, high-pitched note to the bridges. It features a bright timbre that helps balance out the many mid-range synth layers and is relatively low in the mix.

Guitar

Pulsing Electric Guitar
The sole guitar in the song is heard in the verses and pre-choruses. It features a gritty, mid-range tone that gradually increases in volume over the course of its performance.

Effects

White Noise Riser
The white noise riser possesses a bright, noise-based timbre, functioning in an engagement-heightening, transitional role at the end of the pre-choruses and between stanzas 1 and 2 of the second chorus.

Reverse Synth Riser
The reverse synth riser provides an engaging transition between the second pre-chorus and chorus sections. It possesses a reversed saw-wave synth timbre that creates a swelling effect to maximize the chorus’s arrival.

Synth Impact
The synth impact occurs solely in between stanzas 1 and 2 of the bridges, punctuating the second stanza with a downlifting, pitched synth stab.

Instrumental Arrangement: Section By Section

Intro (0:00 – 0:05)

Chord Progression: A (A major: I)

“Cruel Summer’s” intro features the sparsest arrangement in the song, consisting of kick, snare, and synth bass. Note that the sparse intro technique has consistently been one of the two most common techniques used in Hot 100 Top 10 hits over the past decade (along with the backing music technique, which the song also possesses), as it provides a springboard to establish key aspects of the song while providing room for growth in subsequent sections.

Sonically, all the elements have a distinct electronic quality, which along with their timbres and patterns creates an engaging, retro-1980s inspired tapestry that instantly engages the listener.

On the lower end of the frequency spectrum is the kick drum, which plays a vibrant pattern and is processed with a prominent short tail reverb to give it a spacious, big sound. Contrasting it is the tight snare, which covers the mid/high frequency range with its notably brighter, tighter timbre and steady backbeat pulse.

Rounding out the instrumental arrangement is the low-octave staccato synth bass. It establishes the song’s key and provides the mix with a 1980s-inspired texture through its saw-wave timbre, reminiscent of a Moog synthesizer and a mechanical sixteenth-note pattern that possesses a Kraftwork and Devo-esque quality. Also note the brief leap that occurs on the “and” of beats 2 and 4, which subtly heightens interest against its otherwise stagnant pattern.

In addition to the above, the consistency of the arrangement serves as an effective backdrop for the vocoder-processed vocal hook to shine. It serves in both vocal and instrumental capacities, contributing to the section’s texture, rhythm, and catchiness.

At the end of the section, a new snare is heard on the last beat, possessing a grittier timbre that sustains longer than the tight snare. Punctuating the mix, it subtly serves to usher in the ensuing verse without disrupting the groove.

Intro Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Intro Arrangement

Verse 1 (0:05 – 0:17)

Chord Progression: D – E – C#m – F#m (A major: IV-V-iii-vi)

With the intro arrangement remaining in effect to provide cross-section continuity and allow the listener’s full attention to be on Swift’s first installment of the narrative without distraction, the following instrumental elements are added to the mix to heighten cross-section interest:

  • The gritty snare and new snare rimshot are added to the backbeat. Both provide the verse with an interest-heightening textural development that also punctuates the backbeat against Swift’s lead vocal and the vocoder-processed background vocals.
  • A dark synth pad plays a legato pattern over the continuation of the low-octave staccato synth bass from the intro. Possessing a filtered, retro 1980s-tinged timbre, its addition serves a few key purposes, including providing additional texture, color and density to the mix, adding an additional harmonic layer and motion, and providing a subtle dark and foreboding vibe that creates prosody with the song title, “Cruel Summer.”
  • In bar 3, a pulsing synth and electric guitar enter the mix, playing sixteenth-note patterns at a low level. In addition to contributing to the section’s sonic tapestry, they serve to subtly heighten interest midway through the verse and begin to increase tension in anticipation for the impending chorus by way of the ensuing pre-chorus.

Verse 1 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Arrangement

Pre-Chorus 1 (0:17 – 0:28)

Chord Progression: D – E – C#m – F#m – D – E (A major: IV-V-iii-vi-IV-V)

The verse arrangement seamlessly carries over into the pre-chorus and features little development throughout the section. This puts the spotlight on the engaging vocals and lyrics which, along with the continuation of the pulsing synth and guitar, continues to heighten tension and anticipation for the impending chorus.

There are a few subtle developments, however, in the last two bars that serve to further heighten anticipation for the chorus and bolster its impact when it arrives. This culminates into the Hit Songs Deconstructed S.I.A. (section impact accentuator) technique in the last beat of the section, unfolding as follows:

  • The harmonic progression simplifies, sustaining on the V chord at the end of the section, which further heightens tension leading into the chorus.
  • The rimshot is removed from the mix. This results in a slightly smaller, more contained sound on the backbeat that allows the bigger sounding chorus to hit with greater perceived impact.
  • The pulsing synth and guitar increase in volume, which along with the white noise riser, takes tension and anticipation to a climax, resulting in the S.I.A. in the last beat.

Pre-Chorus 1 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 1 Arrangement

Chorus 1 (0:28 – 0:51)

Chord Progression: A – C#m – F#m – D (A major: I-iii-vi-IV)

Following the tension and anticipation-heightening pre-chorus, the chorus hits with a notably denser, “wall of sound” synth-driven production, punctuated by an acoustic-timbred crash and closed hat roll on beat 1.

With the core drum groove and dark synth pad from the pre-chorus providing cross-section cohesion and continuity, the following elements are added to, or changed up, in the chorus:

  • The snare rimshot is added back in along with the new reverberant claps. Together, they further punctuate the backbeat and contribute to the chorus’ deeper, bigger, and more powerful sound.
  • Two new, similarly functioning synth pads are introduced that contribute to density, provide harmonic support and further fill out the frequency spectrum: A 1980s-sounding brass synth pad, which features a saw wave timbre reminiscent of a Roland Juno brass patch, and a bright synth pad that features a digital, resonant timbre that contrasts from the warmer, richer sounds of the other pads in the mix.
  • The vocoder is added back in for the first time since the intro. However, here it is notably lower in the mix and melding with the other synths to contribute unique texture and color the sonic landscape as opposed to delivering a standout vocal hook.
  • A high-octave staccato synth bass replaces its low-octave counterpart heard across the first three sections of the song. While it’s relatively low in the mix, its addition contributes mid-range texture along with subtle forward motion.

Like the verse, and most of the pre-chorus before it, the chorus arrangement remains essentially static from start to finish, save for the familiar crash and hi hat roll that punctuates the arrival of stanza 2. Again, this allows the listener’s full focus to be on the catchy, evocative, hook-based vocals while elevating the section’s emotional connection with the listener.

Chorus 1 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Arrangement

Turnaround (0:51 – 0:53)

Chord Progression: A (A major: I)

Following the dense, high-energy chorus, the brief one-bar turnaround breaks down to the sparser, lower energy intro arrangement, minus the gritty snare. This, along with the notable reverb processing and mid-range focus, creates engaging contrast that both spotlights the return of the “yeah” vocoder hook and provides room for the song to build once again in the ensuing sections.

Turnaround Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Turnaround Arrangement

Verse 2 (0:53 – 1:05)

Chord Progression: D – E – C#m – F#m (A major: IV-V-iii-vi)

Following the brief, transitional turnaround, verse 2 engages the listener at a heightened level through a return to the core verse 1 arrangement along with new and changed up elements. Together, they serve to heighten both familiarity and interest as the song progresses.

Notable verse 2 developments:

  • Brass-timbred synth stabs are uniquely added to the mix, providing engaging like-section contrast. Featured prominently in the mix, they further heighten the song’s retro 1980s vibe and create a subtly more positive mood compared to the darker-timbered verse 1.
  • The dark synth pad, which was featured prominently in verse 1, is now filtered and positioned further back in the mix. This effectively makes way for the brass synth stabs and the comparative shift in mood between verses. 

In the last two bars of the section, the pulsing synth and guitar return, once again heightening tension and anticipation as the verse seamlessly transitions into the pre-chorus.

Verse 2 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Arrangement

Pre-Chorus 2 (1:05 – 1:16)

Chord Progression: D – E – C#m – F#m – D – E (A major: IV-V-iii-vi-IV-V)

The verse 2 – pre-chorus 2 relationship is highly similar as the first time around, which creates structural familiarity in the scope of the song. Pre-chorus 2 initially maintains the verse 2 arrangement, creating cross-section cohesion, followed by the tension-heightening pulsing synth and guitar increasing in volume and the S.I.A. (section impact accentuator) technique being employed in the last two beats.

Here, the arrangement unfolds into the S.I.A. as follows:

  • The rimshot is removed, creating a timbral shift on the backbeat.
  • The remaining backbeat elements, brass synth stabs and low-octave staccato synth bass are then removed for the last two beats, further stripping back the arrangement.
  • Lastly, the kick is omitted from the final beat of the section, leaving the sustained dark synth, pulsing synth and guitar, and white noise and reverse synth risers to usher in the chorus in an engaging manner.

Pre-Chorus 2 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 2 Arrangement

Chorus 2 (1:16 – 1:39)

Chord Progression: A – C#m – F#m – D (A major: I-iii-vi-IV)

The chorus 2 arrangement is highly similar to its chorus 1 counterpart, which bolsters the familiarity factor of the song’s primary “hook center.” However, in addition to the added vocal layers, there are two instrumental differences in the second stanza that, while subtle, contribute to density, texture, color and prevent instrumental redundancy:

  • A low-level bright synth arpeggio is added to the mix. In addition to the above, it also subtly contributes to the section’s rhythmic motion.
  • The synth pads swell to a more prominent level compared to the first time around. This also serves to subtly heighten the section’s excitement factor as it comes to a close. 

Chorus 2 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Chorus 2 Arrangement

Bridge 1 (1:39 – 2:04)

Chord Progression: A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D – A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D – N.C. (A major: I-iii7-vi7-IV-I-iii7-vi7-IV-N.C.)

Bridge 1, which serves as the song’s main “D” (departure) section, provides a notable, engaging shift in the instrumental arrangement compared to the other song sections, along with changeups in vocals and lyrics.

With the core kick and snare groove from the chorus providing cross-section continuity, the mix shifts to a highly rhythmic and notably brighter (higher frequency) instrumental arrangement compared to the preceding sections that works in tandem with Swift’s more excited vocals to bolster the impact of the lyrics.

  • The sub bass and synth pads are removed from the mix, leaving the high-octave staccato synth bass and bright arpeggio synth driving the section forward along with the drums.
  • A high synth drone is introduced, sustaining a high note that further contributes to the section’s higher frequency focus.
  • Bright closed electronic hi hat, closed acoustic hi hat, and open hi hat shift to a steady, thirty-second-note rhythm, driving the song forward with a heightened degree of momentum

In the last three bars of the section, the dark synth pad and brass synth pads are reintroduced. Together, they fill out the mid to low-end of the mix while their gradually increasing volume and cutoff frequency serve to heighten tension, anticipation and engagement leading into the final chorus of the song.

However, instead of leading directly into the chorus, the buildup is subverted by what Hit Songs Deconstructed calls the “Last Chorus Super S.I.A.” technique. Here, an extra bar is tacked onto the end of the bridge, where all the elements are removed from the mix save for Swift’s lead vocal until the last beat when a reverse synth riser ushers in the ensuing chorus. This jarring, unexpected moment notably heightens the listener’s engagement and bolsters the impact of the chorus in the process.

Bridge 1 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Arrangement

Chorus 3 (2:04 – 2:27)

Chord Progression: A – C#m – F#m – D (A major: I-iii-vi-IV)

Following the pronounced, engagement-heightening “Super S.I.A.” technique at the end of the bridge, the third and final chorus hits hard with a return to the familiar, dense arrangement that defines the second stanza of chorus 2. However, to prevent “cookie-cutter” redundancy, the synth layers feature more active rhythmic motion and have brighter timbres, which results in a subtly more excited and energetic vibe. At the end of the section, a dark closed hi hat enters to usher in the second bridge. 

Chorus 3 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Chorus 3 Arrangement

Bridge 2 (2:27 – 2:49)

Chord Progression: A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D (A major: I-iii7-vi7-IV)

The atypical second bridge uniquely fuses the bridge 1 and chorus 3 instrumental arrangements to take the song’s intensity to a grand peak. With the chorus 3 instrumental arrangement remaining in effect to provide cross-section continuity, the high frequency hi hats and high synth drone from bridge 1 are added in, which together, along with a reprise of Swift’s excited bridge 1 vocals, takes the song to an emotional climax.

At the end of the section, the last bar omits the sub bass and high-octave bass from the mix, allowing the low-octave bass to set the stage for the ensuing outro. 

Bridge 2 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Bridge 2 Arrangement

Outro (2:49 – 2:55)

Chord Progression: A (A major: I)

Following the climactic second bridge, the outro notably breaks down to just kick, tight snare, gritty snare and low-octave synth bass. This bookends the song on a familiar note while showcasing the vocoder vocal hook as the song winds down. Note, however, that compared to the similarly arranged intro and turnaround sections, the low-octave synth bass opens the cutoff filter in the last bar. This creates a sense that the outro is building toward something, but instead ends abruptly with a “pulling of the plug” quality at the tail end.

Outro Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Outro Arrangement

Harmonic Progressions


“Cruel Summer” features three core progressions, each with subtle variations.

Progression 1

Progression 1: Variation 1 (Intro, Turnaround, Outro)

A

The first of “Cruel Summer’s” three chord progressions is composed solely of the tonic chord, A major. Delivered through the low-octave staccato synth bass and vocoder, it is featured at three strategic points throughout the song:

  • The intro, where its simplicity locks the listener into the mechanical 1980s-influenced staccato groove and provides room for harmonic growth in subsequent sections.
  • The turnaround, where it harmonically “resets” the song following the first I-A-PC-B sectional progression.
  • The outro, where it resolves the song on a familiar note as it draws to a close. 

Progression 2

Progression 2: Variation 1 (Verses)

D – E – C#m – F#m

Progression 2: Variation 2 (Pre-Choruses)

D – E – C#m – F#m – D – E

The second progression is heard in the verses and pre-choruses, following a core D – E – C#m – F#m (IV – V – iii – vi) pattern with a slight variation in the pre-choruses. The use of subdominant, dominant and tonic tonalities create a cyclical motion that contributes to the forward motion of these sections. Also worth noting is the atypical use of the three-minor chord (C# minor), the darkest chord within the major mode; this provides these sections with an underlying dark quality, which is most notable in the first verse along with the dark-timbred synth pad.

The pre-choruses change things up the last two bars by elongating each chord across a full bar to heighten tension leading into the ensuing chorus. This tension is further bolstered by the use of the dominant V chord (E major), leaving the listener in suspense before the cadential resolution to the I chord (A major) in the subsequent chorus. 

Progression 3

Progression 3: Variation 1 (Choruses)

A – C#m – F#m – D

Progression 3: Variation 2 (Bridges)

A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D – A – C#m7 – F#m7 – D – N.C.

The third progression in “Cruel Summer” is heard in the choruses and bridges, following a core A – C#m – F#m – D (I – iii – vi – IV) progression with subtle variation in the bridges. Following the sustained V chord in the preceding pre-chorus, the chorus progression begins on the resolved root, helping to punctuate the climactic section’s arrival. It then moves to the three-minor chord (C# minor), maintaining the tonic tonality in a dark, engaging manner before brightening slightly on the more typical six-minor chord (F# minor). The chorus progression then concludes on the four-major chord (D major), ending with a subdominant tonality that subtly heightens tension before the subsequent resolution to the root (A major) in the repeated progression or turnaround, bridge and outro sections. This IV-I resolution to the tonic chord is known as a plagal or “Amen” cadence, commonly found in gospel and jazz music as well as contemporary hits (Toosii’s “Favorite Song,” Florida Georgia Line and Bebe Rexha’s “Meant To Be” and Olivia Rodrigo’s “Vampire” are prime examples).

The bridge features a subtle variation from this core progression, employing sevenths on the C# minor (iii) and F# minor (vi) chords to heighten tension.

Vocals


Vocal Production

Lead Vocal Gender

“Cruel Summer” features a solo female lead vocal from Taylor Swift. In the first half of 2023, solo male leads were by far most common among non-hip hop hits at half of all songs, followed distantly by solo female leads at just 17%.

Lead Vocal Gender in the Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2018 – Q2 2023

Cruel Summer Lead Vocal Gender

Lead Vocal Delivery

“Cruel Summer” features an almost entirely sung vocal delivery, save for a few sung/shouted hybrid deliveries in the bridge sections. Despite exclusively sung deliveries continuing to be by far most common among non-hip hop hits, they have been in decline since 2020 while sung/rapped combo deliveries have been on the rise.

Lead Vocal Delivery in the Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2018 – Q2 2023

Cruel Summer Lead Vocal Delivery

Background Vocals

Complementing Swift’s lead are an array of background vocals including unison doubles, octave doubles, above and below the lead harmonies, independent of the lead adlibs, and sustained vocal pads. Together, they serve to heighten interest throughout the song and call attention to key lyrics.

Effects & Processing

“Cruel Summer” features common hit song vocal processing, including reverb, compression, and subtle autotune to heighten the effectiveness of the vocal performance. In addition, a vocoder is used in both a lead and background capacity to provide vocal texture variation and create one of the song’s notable hooks.

Vocal Production Visualization Key

Lead: Female (Taylor Swift): Taylor Swift’s lead vocal
BGV 1: Female (Unison Double): Background vocal doubles in unison with the lead
BGV 2: Female (High Octave Double): Background vocal doubles an octave above the lead
BGV 3: Female (Low Octave Double): Background vocal doubles an octave below the lead
BGV 4: Female (Lead Harmony) (Above): Background vocals that harmonize with the lead on different pitches above the melody
BGV 5: Female (Lead Harmony) (Below): Background vocals that harmonize with the lead on different pitches below the melody
BGV 6: Female (Adlibs): Background vocals featured independently from the lead
BGV 7: Female (BGV Pad): Multiple background vocals stacked and sustained to create a pad-like effect
Vocoder: Vocoder vocal hook independent from all vocals, functions in a background and lead capacity

S: Sung
SH:
Shouted
BGV:
Background vocals

Underlined Lyrics: Denotes unison and octave doubles with the lead; one underline denotes unison double(s), and double underlines denote additional octave double(s)
Color-Coded Lyrics: 
Denotes lyrics sung in unison/octaves with the lead (light green), in harmony with the lead (dark green), independent of the lead (orange), and the vocoder layer (blue). Note that this matches the color-coding of the above vocal arrangement overview table.

Vocal Delivery Arrangement Overview

Cruel Summer Vocal Production Overview

Verse 1

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Vocal Production Table

Verse 1 introduces Swift’s lead vocal into the mix, which is positioned up the middle and processed with compression to help punctuate its presence.

Complementing it are the “oh yeah, you’re right, I want it” background vocals at the end of each line. Panned to the right, featured lower in the mix, and processed with vocoder, these vocals serve as catchy “nano hook” responses to Swift’s lead while maintaining vocal cohesion with the intro. 

Pre-Chorus 1

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 1 Vocal Production Table

Pre-chorus 1 continues with the same lead vocal characteristics as the preceding verse, maintaining cross-section continuity and cohesion. The sole changeup occurs in line 2 with the addition of a high-octave double, which serves a few key purposes: It prevents Swift’s lower-register lead from becoming too buried and losing its impact, calls further attention to the lyric, and heightens interest leading into the developed melody and lyrics in lines 3 and 4. Note that an important reason for omitting the double on these lines was to enable the more vocally robust chorus to stand out in comparison.

Chorus 1

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Vocal Production Table

Following Swift’s mainly solo lead performance in the verse and pre-chorus, the chorus introduces unison and low-octave doubles, which are featured throughout the section. This vocal development serves a few key purposes:

  • The unison double bolsters the presence of Swift’s soaring, impassioned vocal and enables it to further cut through the mix. Without it, the thinner vocal quality could reduce the section’s emotional impact.
  • The low-octave double provides her vocal with more weight and maintains range continuity coming out of the lower-register pre-chorus.
  • The vocal layering jibes with the “wall of sound” synths to create a notably denser arrangement that both complements the lyrics and enables the chorus to further stand out against the preceding sections. 

In addition, the decision to include unison and octave doubles as opposed to multi-pitch harmony throughout the chorus provides room for vocal production growth in subsequent sections.

However, similar to the pre-chorus, there is one line in the section that features a more developed vocal compared to the others. Here, it occurs in line 6 on the vocal fragment, “breakable heaven, but,” which features harmony above the lead for the first time in the song (as opposed to a double). This seemingly minor development is important for a few key reasons:

  • It calls attention to the chorus’ most clever, standout lyric.
  • It subtly heightens interest within the otherwise stagnant lead vocal qualities of the two-stanza section.
  • It enables the ensuing catchy nonsense lyric to further standout in comparison, which doesn’t feature the layer. 

Turnaround

Cruel Summer Turnaround Vocal Production Table

Following the chorus, the brief turnaround reverts to the vocoder processed “yeah” from the intro. However, compared to the intro, here it is featured at a lower level in the mix and processed with a greater degree of reverb. This provides it with a less direct quality which, along with the thinned-out arrangement, allows the more direct verse that follows to enter with increased perceived impact while subtly reinforcing the hook in the listener’s mind.

Verse 2

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Vocal Production Table

The first line in verse 2 features the same lead and background (vocoder) vocal production qualities as its verse 1 counterpart. This creates like-section familiarity that allows the listener to more easily connect with the section and have their full attention on the narrative development. However, to help heighten interest both on a like-section and cross-section basis, harmonizing vocals are uniquely added above the lead in line 2.

In addition, another vocal layer an octave above the lead is added on the lyric “we’re not trying” in line 2, which serves to further interest with the subtle burst of color it provides. 

Pre-Chorus 2

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 2 Vocal Production Table

Pre-chorus 2 features nearly identical vocal production qualities as its pre-chorus 1 counterpart. This helps to provide like-section cohesion against the atypical pre-chorus lyrical changeups (most hit songs feature the same pre-chorus lyrics across iterations). The sole exception is a greater use of delay in line 3, which provides a subtly engaging like-section development on the only lyrically identical line in the section.

Chorus 2

Cruel Summer Chorus 2 Vocal Production Table

Chorus 2 features the same vocal qualities as its chorus 1 counterpart, with one exception: The low lead harmony is featured across lines 5 and 6 as opposed to just line 6. This serves to heighten interest at the top of the second stanza while maintaining vocal production cohesion with chorus 1.

Bridge 1

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Vocal Production Table

The two-stanza, bridge 1 “D” (departure) section features unique vocal production characteristics that, along with the melodic, lyrical and instrumental arrangement changeups, serves to notably heighten listener interest and engagement in the scope of the song.

Stanza 1
While the first line of the bridge begins in a similar manner as the verses with a solo lead vocal across the lyrics “I’m drunk in the,” it is followed by harmony above the lead on the lyric “back of the car,” which provides a burst of engaging color and excitement. This same solo/harmonized technique is then employed in line 3, which creates structural familiarity within the stanza.

Sandwiched between them is line 2, which is entirely devoid of lead vocal layers. Along with heightening line-to-line interest, this decision allows the first adlib heard in the song, the high-register, multi-layered “oh” at the end of the line, to further stand out in comparison.

The stanza concludes with the first instance of a high-register sung/shouted hybrid vocal, which is accompanied by a similar harmonized background vocal. Along with notably heightening engagement at the end of the stanza, it also serves to highlight the all-important lyric, “I don't wanna keep secrets just to keep you.”

Stanza 2
Line 5 at the top of stanza 2 begins in similar fashion as stanza 1. However, instead of adding and removing the high harmony throughout, it maintains it across lines 6-8, which creates a heightened sense of excitement, intensity, and cross-stanza interest. Also contributing to this are low-level sustained vocal “ah’s” that provide a pad-like texture that pairs perfectly with the synths.

All of the layers are then abruptly removed in line 9, along with the full instrumental arrangement. Filling this void is the unique sung/shouted, “He looks up, grinnin' like a devil,” which is processed with copious reverb. Together, these qualities serve to emphasize the standout lyric and enable the dense chorus that follows to hit with increased perceived impact (reference the “Super S.I.A. technique” in the Instrumental Arrangement and Energy sections of the report).

Chorus 3

Cruel Summer Chorus 3 Vocal Production Table

The third and final chorus in the song features highly similar vocal production characteristics as its chorus 2 counterpart. The two subtle differences, which most likely go unnoticed by the average listener, are Swift’s slightly more present performance and the brief high harmony layer included on the lyric “no” in line 6.

Bridge 2

Cruel Summer Bridge 2 Vocal Production Table

The bridge 2 vocal production is largely similar to its bridge 1 counterpart save for the lead harmony being featured throughout. This, along with the denser instrumental arrangement, takes the song’s excitement and intensity to a grand peak before heading into the brief outro.

Outro

Cruel Summer Outro Vocal Production Table

The outro returns to the sparse vocoder qualities of the intro and turnaround. Here, it is processed with more reverb than the intro (like the turnaround), which enables the piercing synth to take front and center while the song concludes on a familiar and engaging note.

Vocal Melody

Cruel Summer Full Vocal Melody Graph

Key

Section Focus
This section of the report focuses on lead vocal melody. For details on background vocals, please refer to the Vocal Production section of the report.

Part Graphs
Graphs: Reflect Lead vocals (excludes harmony)
Numbers in the graphs: Depict the scale degree of each note
Curved Line: Slur across two or more pitches

Vocal Melody Part Classifications
Main melodic parts, such as upper-case A,B and C, reflect the main melodic structure of each line in a song section.
Sub-melodic parts, such as lower-case a, b, c, reflect melodic structure both within and across lines.

The vocal melody part classifications in each section are specific to that particular section type (i.e., verses, pre-choruses, etc.) and do not relate to other section types (i.e., part A classification in verse 1 does not relate to part A in the chorus, but part A in verse 1 does relate to part A in verse 2).

Vocal melody parts are determined by pitches, rhythms, and melodic pattern commonalities.

Intro & Outro

The first and last vocal heard in “Cruel Summer” is the highly simple “yeah,” which is repeated four consecutive times. Situated on the root and delivered with a quarter-note rhythm broken up by quarter rests, it establishes the song’s key (A major), contributes to the steady groove, and serves as an instantly identifiable hook with its vocoder processing at the top of the song.

The vocal is then subsequently reinforced in a more subtle, background manner in the turnaround before returning more prominently in the outro, concluding the song on a familiar and catchy note.  

Intro & Outro Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Intro Vocal Melody Graph
Cruel Summer Intro Vocal Melody Table
Cruel Summer Intro Sheet Music

Verses

Overview

Swift’s lead melody in “Cruel Summer’s” verses largely adheres to Hit Songs Deconstructed’s K.I.S.S. ME principle (keep it simple, singable and memorable). Among their K.I.S.S. ME qualities are the limited range of a major second, mainly stagnant motion, and simple eighth and sixteenth note-driven rhythms. These qualities enable the listener to easily connect with both installments of the narrative while their directness bolsters the emotional impact of the lyrics.

The sole deviation from the K.I.S.S. ME principle is the verse’s lengthy lines, which land between 14 and 22 syllables. However, this is offset by subtle rhythmic segmentation that makes them easier to digest.

Note that while both verses are very similar, they possess subtle melodic and rhythmic differences that are necessary to accommodate lyrical changeups and prevent “cookie-cutter” redundancy.  

Melodic Structure Overview & Detail

Verse 1 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Graph

Verse 2 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Vocal Melody Graph

Intro & Outro Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Intro Vocal Melody Graph

Verse 1 Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Table
Cruel Summer Verse 1 Sheet

Verse 2 Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Table
Cruel Summer Verse 2 Sheet

Melodic Structure Detail

*Note that all images and analysis shown below pertains to verse 1 unless otherwise noted. Differences between verses 1 and 2, if any, are detailed in each line grouping’s analysis.

Lines 1 & 2

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Line 1 Vocal Melody Graph
Cruel Summer Verse 1 Line 2 Graph
Cruel Summer Verse 1 Sheet
Line 1

Part a1: Fe-ver dream high in the qui-et of the night
Part a2: You know that I caught it

Line 1, the song’s true opening line following the intro’s vocoder-processed “yeah’s,” is composed of subparts a1 and a2. Both consist of simple eighth and sixteenth note-driven patterns mainly situated on scale degree 2, which result in a forward-moving, subtly tense melody. Subpart a2 then resolves the melody with a step down to scale degree 1 at the very end.

While the line is relatively lengthy at 17 syllables, the strategic interspersion of eighth notes against sixteenths create subtle segmentation that makes the full line easier to connect with and digest:

  • “Fe-ver dream high / in the qui-et of the night / you know that I caught it.”

Note, however, that the segmentation is most notable between the lyrics “night” and “you.” This is both due to the perceived lyrical phrase segmentation (i.e., “Fe-ver dream high in the qui-et of the night / you know that I caught it”) and the fact that the subpart a2’s repeat identically across lines while the preceding a1 and a3 segments vary slightly.

In addition, note that the directness of the melody creates effective prosody with the lyric to heighten the all-important opening line’s emotional impact and set the stage for what comes next.

Line 2

Part a3: Bad, bad boy, shin-y toy with a price
Part a2: You know that I bought it

Line 2 is composed of subparts a3 and a2. Highly similar to line 1, subpart a3 varies the rhythm and starting pitch slightly to accommodate the lyrics and prevent “cookie cutter” redundancy, while the subpart a2 repetition heightens cross-line cohesion. 

Pre-Choruses

Overview

Following the largely stagnant, lengthy, repetitive verse melodies, the pre-choruses provide engaging cross-section contrast through the incorporation of non-K.I.S.S. ME qualities including a notably wider melodic range (an octave as opposed to a major second), more melodic variation and large intervallic leaps.

Balancing the deviations from the K.I.S.S. ME principle are their shorter melodic segments created by rests; simple, easy-to-lock into rhythms; ample repetition; and each melody predominantly focused within a limited range, despite their notable leaps. These qualities ensure that the listener still easily connects while simultaneously focusing attention and heightening engagement leading into the ensuing chorus. 

Melodic Structure Overview & Detail

Pre-Chorus Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 1 Vocal Melody Graph

Verse 1 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Vocal Melody Graph

Verse 2 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Vocal Melody Graph

Intro & Outro Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Intro Vocal Melody Graph

Pre-Chorus Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 1 Table
Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 1 Sheet

Melodic Structure Detail

Lines 1 & 2

Cruel Summer PC1 Vocal Melody Graph
Cruel Summer PC 1 Sheet
Line 1

Part a1: Kill-ing me slow
Part a1: Out the win-dow

Line 1 is composed of two back-to-back occurrences of subpart a1, separated by an eighth rest. Picking up where the verses leave off, both feature simple, short, repetitive patterns centered on the root before concluding with a drop to scale degree 5. Together, they provide engaging contrast against the longer, continuous flow of the verses and help to set up the impending chorus in the process.

Furthermore, note that the descending leap of a fourth at the end of each segment serves to bolster the rhyme connection between “slow” and “win-DOW” along with heightening melodic interest.

Line 2

Part b1: I'm al-ways wait-ing for you to be wait-ing be-low

Line 2 is composed of subpart b1. Picking up where line 1 leaves off on scale degree 5, it leaps back up to a repeated pattern on the root before dropping back down to scale degree 5, where it remains until the 4-3-1 descent at the end, which is the lowest melodic point in the song. Note that this descent also creates effective prosody with the downward-focused lyric, “waiting below.”

While this line is notably longer than line 1 and doesn’t possess any segmentation, its consistent sixteenth note-driven rhythm and simplistic melody imparts a roll-off-the-tongue quality that still easily connects with the listener while creating engaging contrast against line 1. 

Lines 3 & 4

Cruel Summer PC1 Lines 3-4 Graph
Cruel Summer PC1 Lines 3-4 Sheet
Line 3

Part a2: Dev-ils roll the dice
Part a2: An-gels roll their eyes

Line 3 is composed of subpart a2. While it begins in the same manner as its line 1 counterpart with repeated sixteenth notes on the root, instead of concluding with a leap down a fourth to scale degree 5, it instead leaps up an octave. This effective balance of repetition and contrast heightens both memorability and interest while further heightening excitement and anticipation for the impending chorus.

In addition, as is the case in line 1, the leaps serve to bolster the rhyme connection of the lyrics, “dice” and “eyes,” and call attention to the intriguing lyrical development.

Line 4

Part c: What does-n’t kill me makes me want you more

Line 4 is composed of subpart c. While it shares the commonality with its line 2 counterpart of beginning with a succession of root notes and continuing with a mainly stagnant melody, it differs in its melodic focus and rhythms.

Melodically, after starting on the root, it leaps up to scale degree 3 as opposed to descending to scale degree 5, where it resides save for a brief dip down to scale degree 2 towards the end. Rhythmically, it features a more varied, syncopated rhythm compared to the sixteenth note-based line 2. These contrasting qualities serve to further heighten interest, tension and anticipation for the chorus that directly follows.

Choruses

Overview

Just like their “wall of sound” instrumental arrangements, the choruses notably stand out against the other sections in the song through their contrasting melodic qualities. Among them are the significantly higher ranges; soaring, sustained melodies; and catchy, engaging use of melisma (runs).

In addition to heightening interest, these qualities work hand-in-hand with Swift’s stellar vocal performance and the engaging vocal production to bring the lyrics to life and bolster the listener’s emotional connection with the section, and the song.  

Melodic Structure Overview & Detail

Chorus Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Graph

Pre-Chorus Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer PC1 Graph

Verse 1 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Graph

Verse 2 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Graph

Intro & Outro Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Intro Graph

Chorus Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Table
Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Sheet

Melodic Structure Detail

*Note that all images and analysis shown below pertains to chorus1 unless otherwise noted. Differences between choruses 1, 2, and 3 if any, are detailed in each line grouping’s analysis.

Stanza 1

Lines 1 & 2

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Lines 1-2 Graph
Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Sheet
Line 1

Part a: And it’s new
Part b: The shape of your bod-y

Line 1 is composed of subparts a and b. Subpart a begins the chorus with an engaging leap of a sixth up to the root, followed by sustaining on a 3-2 slur on the lyric “And it’s new.” Along with notably heightening interest at the top of the section, this high-register vocal also serves to bolster the lyric’s emotional impact and set the stage for the developments that lay ahead.

Subpart b follows with a melodic shape that’s in line with the verse melodies, albeit an octave above. This fosters melodic familiarity in the scope of the song while the higher register keeps the chorus’ emotional intensity at a high.

Line 2

Part a: It’s blue
Part b: The feel-ing I’ve got, and it’s

Line 2 is identical to line 1, save for slight rhythmic variations to accommodate the new lyrics.

Note that there is no melodic or rhythmic segmentation between lines, with the eighth rest appearing after the lyric “blue.” This achieves the following:

  • The omission of the rest provides a continuous flow between lines.
  • The inclusion of the rest after “blue” makes the section easier to digest and remember while bolstering the melodic and rhyme connections between “blue” and “new” along with their sustained qualities.

Lines 3 & 4

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Graph Lines 3-4
Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Sheet Lines 3-4
Line 3

Part c: Ooh woah-oh

Line 3 is composed of subpart c. Beginning a third above where line 2 leaves off, it subsequently leaps to scale degree 5, the highest pitch in the song, before generally progressing down to the root with rises and falls along the way. This, along with its engaging fast-to-slow rhythm, achieves the following:

  • The melismatic quality and large range further showcases Swift’s stellar vocal chops.
  • The pairing with the nonsense lyric cleverly communicates the emotion Swift feels without the need to outright say it (i.e., a “show, don’t tell” approach).
  • It foreshadows and subsequently reinforces the song title hook melody that follows.
Line 4

Part c: It’s a cruel sum-mer

Line 4 is nearly identical to its line 3 counterpart, save for the “it’s a” pickup on scale degree 5 that lead into the song title hook.

Stanza 2

Lines 5 & 6

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Lines 5-6 Graph
Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Lines 5-6 Sheet
Line 5

Part a: It’s cool
Part b: That’s what I tell ‘em

Line 5 is nearly identical to its line 1 counterpart, save for slight rhythmic differences.

Line 6

Part a: No rules
Part b:
 In break-a-ble heav-en, but

Line 6 is nearly identical to its line 2 counterpart, save for slight rhythmic differences. 

Lines 7 & 8

Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Lines 7-8 Graph
Cruel Summer Chorus 1 Lines 7-8 Sheet
Line 7

Part c: Ooh woah-oh

Line 7 is identical to its line 3 counterpart.

Line 8

Part c: It’s a cruel sum-mer
Part d: With you

Line 8 is nearly identical to its line 4 counterpart, save for the extra subpart d melody at the end. Its addition serves to both accommodate the important lyric and bring the section to a resolved conclusion.

Bridges

Overview

The bridge is mainly comprised of repetitive A.M.P. (alternating melodic pattern)-like melodies that both adhere and to, and depart from, the K.I.S.S. ME principle.

The first three lines in both stanzas feature wide A.M.P.-like motion that is both easy to connect with and accentuates the emotion of the storytelling lyrics. In contrast, the tighter, higher register and more direct qualities of lines 4, 8 and 9, while more difficult to sing, accentuate the impact of key lyrics and take the section’s emotional intensity to a climax along with Swift’s sung/shouted hybrid deliveries.

Furthermore, note that the descending 1-5 melodic progressions throughout the section foster familiarity with the pre-chorus, which makes the song more cohesive and memorable in an under-the-radar manner that the listener will likely not even realize.

Melodic Structure Overview & Detail

Bridge 1 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Bridge Graph

Chorus Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Chorus Graph

Pre-Chorus Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer PC1 Graph

Verse 1 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Graph

Verse 2 Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Graph

Intro & Outro Melodic Direction: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Intro Graph

Bridge 1 Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Table
Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Sheet

Melodic Structure Detail

Lines 1 & 2

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 1-2 Graph
Cruel Summer Bridge Lines 1-2 Sheet
Line 1

Part a1: I’m drunk in the back of the car

Line 1 is composed of subpart a1. It features simple, A.M.P.-like (alternating melodic pattern) motion that alternates between scale degrees 1 and 5 with an equally simple eighth and sixteenth note-driven rhythm.

Line 2

Part a2: And I cried like a ba-by com-in’ home from the bar

Line 2 is composed of subpart a2. Highly similar to line 1, it keeps the listener locked in the catchy flow while its longer length and subtly altered rhythm accommodate the new lyrics and maintain interest. 

Lines 3 & 4

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 3-4 Graph
Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 3-4 Sheet
Line 3

Part a1: Said, “I’m fine,” but it was-n’t true

Line 3 is composed of subpart a1. While it is highly similar to its line 1, a1 counterpart, it features subtle melodic and rhythmic differences that help to prevent redundancy and maintain interest.

Line 4

Part b1: I don’t wan-na keep se-crets just to keep you, and I

Line 4 is composed of subpart b1. It provides engaging contrast against the other lines by leaping a sixth to scale degree 3 and then following a tight A.M.P. pattern across scale degrees 2 and 3 before stepping down to the root at the end. Driven with a vibrant eighth and sixteenth note rhythm, this variation takes the stanza to an emotionally excited peak that effectively serves the lyric along with Swift’s unique sung/shouted hybrid delivery.

Interesting to note is the conclusion on the root at the end. While this melodically resolves the first stanza, the lyric “and I” leaves it lyrically unresolved and maintains anticipation for the second stanza that follows.

Stanza 2

Lines 5 & 6

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 5-6 Graph
Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 5-6 Sheet

Lines 5 and 6 are nearly identical to their lines 1 and 2 counterparts, save for slight rhythmic differences. is composed of subpart a1. It is nearly identical to its line 1 counterpart, save for slight rhythmic differences.

Lines 7 – 9

Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 7-9 Graph
Cruel Summer Bridge 1 Lines 7-9 Sheet
Line 7

Part a1: And I scream, “For what-ev-er it’s worth”

Line 7 is composed of subpart a1. It is nearly identical to its line 3 counterpart, save for slight rhythmic differences.

Line 8

Part b2: I love you ain’t that the worst thing you ev-er heard?”

Line 8 is composed of subpart b2. While highly similar to its line 4 counterpart, it features rhythmic variation and more stagnant motion that serves to maintain interest and deliver the lyrics in a more direct manner. In addition, note that the rhythmic variation serves to subtly highlight the key lyrics, “love you” and “worst thing.” The line concludes on scale degree 3 as opposed to the root, which serves to transition into the unique line 9 that follows. 

Line 9

Part b3: He looks up, grin-nin’ like a dev-il

Line 9 is composed of subpart b3. The most direct line in the section, it is entirely centered on scale degree 3 and possesses a string of eighth and sixteenth notes. Along with heightening interest in the full accompaniment pull “Super S.I.A.” (section impact accentuator – see the instrumental arrangement and energy section for details), the varied rhythm across the “he looks up” and “grinnin’ like a devil” segments serve to highlight each lyrical aspect and bolster the line’s overall impact along with Swift’s sung/shouted hybrid delivery.

The line and section conclude on scale degree 2 as opposed the root, which heightens tension leading into the ensuing final chorus.

Lyrics & Rhymes


Rhyme Schemes

Overview

“Cruel Summer” features an abundance of expertly crafted rhymes and other lyrical connection accentuators that bolsters the song’s ability to connect and resonate. Among them are logically unfolding end-of-line rhyme schemes and a plethora of strategically placed internal rhymes, double rhymes, alliterations, lyrical repetitions, cross-section commonalities and unique pronunciations to make rhymes happen where they otherwise wouldn’t.

At-A-Glance: End-Of-Line Rhymes Section-By-Section

Key

A, B & C: End-of-line rhymes
X: Non-rhymes
Lyric/Syllable: The primary rhyme at the end of each line
Underline: Repetitive lyrics
Colors and rhyme schemes are unique to each section

*For simplicity of analysis, note that only lyrics connected by both rhyme and another notable characteristic (i.e., proximity, placement, melodic connection, etc.) are shown in each table. Lyrics that rhyme but are otherwise unconnected are not noted.

Cruel Summer Rhymes Overview

Intro, Turnaround & Outro

Cruel Summer Intro Rhymes

“Cruel Summer’s” intro, turnaround and outro simply feature the repetition of the lyric “yeah.”

Verse 1

Cruel Summer Verse 1 Rhymes

End-Of-Line Rhymes
Verse 1 follows a two-line, AA rhyme scheme, both concluding with the lyric “it.”

Internal Rhymes, Alliteration & Other Connection Accentuators
In addition to its end-of-line rhymes, verse 1 features a host of other lyrical connection accentuators, including:

  • The “caught” and “bought” rhymes, which create a double end-of-line rhyme with the lyric “it.”
  • The “the night” and “a price” double rhymes at the end of the first segment in both lines.
  • The similarly placed “EYE”-sounding internal rhymes within both lines.
  • The “bad, bad boy” alliteration at the beginning of line 2, which is complemented by the “boy” / “toy” internal rhyme.
  • The “you know that I” repetition in the second segment of both lines. 

Verse 2

Cruel Summer Verse 2 Rhymes

End-Of-Line Rhymes
Like verse 1, verse 2 follows a two-line AA end-of-line rhyme scheme. However, the rhyming lyrics differ with the “-ing” commonalities.

Internal Rhymes, Alliteration & Other Connection Accentuators
Also like verse 1, verse 2 features additional lyrical connection accentuators that serve to heighten cohesion and memorability. They include:

  • The “dy-” and “try-” rhymes, which create double end-of-line rhymes in the lyrics “dy-ing” and “try-ing.”
  • The “low” / “glow” internal rhymes in line 1. Note the similar positioning as “high” and “QUI-et” in verse 1, which creates structural familiarity across verse sections.
  • The “just” / “up” rhyme in line 2, which features similar placement as “low” / “glow” in line 1.
  • The alliteration in the lyrics “hang” and “head” at the beginning of line 1 and “try-ing times” in line 2.
  • The similarly placed “-ing,” which appears at nearly the same spot internally and at the end of each line.
  • The repetition of the lyric “not” preceding the two end-of-line rhymes. This is another commonality shared with verse 1, which features lyrical repetition preceding its end-of-line rhymes. 

Pre-Chorus 1

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 1 Rhymes

End-Of-Line Rhymes
Pre-Chorus 1 follows a four-line AAXA rhyme scheme. Lines 1, 2, and 4 share the “OH”-sounding commonality in “win-dow,” “be-low,” and “more.” Note that Swift alters her pronunciation of “more” to emphasize the “OH” sound and bolster the connection to “win-DOW” and “be-LOW.”

Internal Rhymes, Alliteration & Other Connection Accentuators
Like the verses, the first pre-chorus features a host of other connection accentuators that bolsters its ability to connect and be remembered. They include:

  • The strategic internal rhymes at the end of segmented phrases in lines 1 and 3. “Slow” in line 1 further bolsters the connection of the “OH” end-of-line rhyme, while the “dice” / “eyes” rhyme in line 3 heightens its connectability despite its lack of an end-of-line rhyme.
  • Use of alliteration in lines 2 and 4, most notably with the line 4 lyrics “me, makes, me.”
  • Two instances of repetitive lyrics: “waiting” in line 2 and the similarly placed “roll” in line 3. 

Pre-Chorus 2

Cruel Summer Pre-Chorus 2

End-Of-Line Rhymes
Pre-Chorus 2 differs from pre-chorus 1 both in terms of its lyrics, save for line 3 (an atypical quality found in hit songs), and its rhyme scheme. Its four lines follow an ABAB scheme, with the A’s connected by the “EYE”-sounding rhyme in the lyrics, “knife” and “eyes,” and the B’s connected by the “OH”-sounding rhyme in the lyrics, “bone” and “oh.”

Internal Rhymes, Alliteration & Other Connection Accentuators
Further bolstering the connection value of pre-chorus 2 are the other following lyrical connection accentuators:

  • The “EYE”-sounding internal rhymes at the end of the first segment in lines 1 and 3, both of which reinforce the end-of-line rhymes.
  • The abundant “UH”-sounding rhymes across lines 1 and 2, which heighten cohesion against the different-sounding end-of-line rhymes.
  • The double “know” / “oh” end-of-line rhyme in line 4.
  • Alliteration in lines 2 and 3.
  • Commonalities with pre-chorus 1, including the repetition of line 3; the use of the “OH”-sounding end-of-line rhyme; and the “EYE” end-of-line rhyme, which was initially featured as the sole non-end-of-line rhyme in both segments of line 3 in pre-chorus 1. 

Choruses

Cruel Summer Chorus Rhymes

End-Of-Line Rhymes
The chorus interestingly goes against one’s likely expectations of a song’s primary “hook center” featuring the greatest degree of end-of-line rhymes. Instead, only two adjacent lines – lines 3 and 4 (“oh” and “sum-AH”, respectively) have an end-of-line rhyme connection, which is mainly due to Swift’s creative pronunciation of “summer” to make the rhyme happen. Note that this is well warranted since these two lines are the song’s main vocal hooks (along with the vocoder “yeah”). While lines 7 and 8 feature the same core lyrics, note that line 8 tacks on the lyric “with you” at the end, which breaks the end-of-line rhyme connection present in lines 3 and 4.

Internal Rhymes, Alliteration & Other Connection Accentuators
In lieu of strong end-of-line rhymes, the chorus features a host of internal rhymes, alliteration and repetitive lyrics that ensures it still fully connects and resonates. They include:

  • The similarly placed “OOH”-sounding rhyme toward the beginning of each line. Note that the melodic variation against the melodies that precede and follow enables them to further stand out and connect.
  • The “AH”-sounding rhyme toward the end of lines 1 and 2 in the lyrics “BOD-y” and “got,” which are close proximity to where an end-of-line rhyme would be.
  • The similarly placed double rhymes “tell ‘em” and “heav-en” at the end of lines 5 and 6. Note that the lyric “but” at the end of line 6 prohibits this from being considered an end-of-line rhyme.
  • Alliteration across lines 1 & 2 (“body” / “blue”), and line 6 (“break-a-ble”).
  • The repetition of the lyric “it,” along with its similar placement at/near the beginning of lines 1, 2, 4, 5 and 8).
  • The repetition of the nonsense lyric and song title hook across the last two lines of both stanzas. 

Bridges

Cruel Summer Bridge Rhymes

End-Of-Line Rhymes
Bridge 1 follows an AAXX/BBCCX rhyme scheme across its two stanzas. The A rhyme scheme features the “AR”-sounding commonality in the lyrics “car” and “bar,” the B scheme features the “AY”-sounding commonality in the lyrics “gate” and “fate,” and the C commonality features the “ER”-sounding commonality in “worth” and “heard.” Note that while lines 3 and 4 feature a close end-of-line rhyme in the lyrics “true” and “blue,” it is prevented by the inclusion of the lyric “and I” at the end of line 4.

Bridge 2 is identical to bridge 1, save for the omission of line 9.

Internal Rhymes, Alliteration & Other Connection Accentuators
In addition to its end-of-line rhymes, the bridge features a host of other connection accentuators, including a plethora of internal rhymes, strategic repetition and alliteration:

  • The similarly placed “UH” internal rhyme, which appears in every line in lyrics including “the, “a,” “just,” “snuck,” and the creative pronunciation of the lyric “to” as “tUH” in lines 4 and 6, among others.
  • The similarly placed “EYE” internal rhyme, which appears at or near the beginning of each line in stanza 1.
  • The repetition of the lyrics “and I,” “just to” and “keep.”
  • Alliteration in lines 2 and 5 in lyrics “ba-by” and “gar-den gate,” respectively.

Narrative

Overview

“Cruel Summer” is a love/relationships-themed song about a protagonist (Taylor Swift) and her intense desire for a bad boy love interest that she knows will likely not end well. The song makes great use of the A.I.D.E. principle (action, imagery, detail devices, emotion) to convey the story in a compelling manner, while the abundance of clever, metaphorical lyricism engages the listener on a deep level. However, the listener is always able to grasp what it’s all about, which is a testament to Swift’s masterful lyric-writing skills.  

In addition, the lyricism and overarching story creates intrigue as to which boyfriend Taylor Swift is singing about and also cleverly relates to other songs within her body of work. An example is the standout lyric, “devils roll the dice, angels roll their eyes,” which appears on a board game in Swift’s “Lover” music video. While this reference will likely go unnoticed by the casual listener, for diehard Swift fans it’s an easter egg of a find.

Lyrical Theme Trends

“Cruel Summer” is a love/relationships-themed song with a combination of romantic/being in love and breakup/love-gone-bad subject matter. Over the past five years and beyond, the overarching love/relationships theme has consistently been most popular among non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits, fluctuating between three-quarters and 87% of songs.

In terms of its subject matter, breakup/love-gone-bad has nearly tripled in popularity since 2022, rising to 60% of songs in the first half of 2023. Conversely, romantic/being in love subject matter has been in decline over the same period, accounting for just 17% of songs in the first half of 2023.

Lyrical Themes In Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2018 – Q2 2023

Narrative Flow: At-A-Glance

Key

Pers. (Perspective): The character whose perspective is most reflected in each line (Swift, lover, both, others)
Tone: The tone of the line, either positive (P) or negative (N)
Parentheses: P.O.V., Tone or A.I.D.E. component is implied and/or relates to the preceding line
A.I.D.E. Table: Reflects the type of lyricism being used in each line (action, imagery, detail devices, emotion) and whether the lyric is common or clever.

  • Action: Describes a past, present or future physical action.
  • Imagery: Describing something or someone that conjures up an image.
  • Detail Devices: Enhancing the lyrics through notable descriptive adjectives, adverbs, idioms, metaphors and similes.
  • Emotion: Lyrics that describe the way someone feels or elicit a feeling

Colors are specific to the table at hand

Intro & Outro

The first lyric heard in “Cruel Summer” is the vocoder-processed, repetitive “yeah.” It serves as a catchy, instantly recognizable hook at the top of the song and is subsequently reinforced in the turnaround and outro.  

Verse 1

Overview

Verse 1 officially begins “Cruel Summer’s” love/relationships-themed narrative by establishing Swift’s intense desire for someone that may come with negative consequences over the course of two lines. It is communicated entirely from Swift’s point-of-view, using an effective combination of positive and negative tones and clever and common lyricism to impactfully convey the story while ensuring that the listener can still easily grasp what it’s all about.

Key Points

  • While the song’s official opening line, “Fever dream high in the quiet of the night, you know that I caught it,” is captivating and intriguing, it means little without the important substantiation that follows on line 2, “Bad, bad boy, shiny toy with a price, you know that I bought it,” which puts it into perspective.  This exemplifies the importance of always ensuring that the listener can grasp what is going on in the story.
  • Both lines feature lyrics that possess a combination of positive and negative tones, which sets the tone for the overall story that lies ahead
    • A “fever dream” is a highly vivid dream that is often distressing, which sets the stage for the problematic nature of the relationship. However, when taken into account with the “high in the quiet of the night” lyric that follows, it infers Swift’s intense desire for someone that she can’t get out of her head.
    • “Bad, bad boy, shiny toy with a price” conveys a few key things. They include her love interest’s bad boy persona, insight into the kind of person Swift is attracted to along with his implied good looks (“shiny toy”), the beginning of the relationship (a “shiny toy” is also something that is new and desirable), and the fact that the relationship might not end well (“with a price”).
    • The lyrics “you know that I caught it” and “you know that I bought it” cleverly convey Swift’s full desire and commitment to being with this person.
  • The vocoder-processed background vocals, “oh yeah, you’re right, I want it,” convey Swift’s intense desire for this person in a straight-forward, embellishing, “nano hook” manner. Furthermore, note that the vocal’s processing and background positioning can be construed as Swift’s subconscious depicting what she really wants, despite the possible negative aspects conveyed in her lead vocal. This cleverly provides the narrative with increased clarity against the metaphorical lyrics.

Pre-Chorus 1

Overview

Pre-chorus 1 elaborates on the verse premise in a fresh, intriguing way. Communicated mainly from Swift’s point-of-view, it uses all A.I.D.E. components to further convey her intense desire to take a chance on her “bad boy” love interest, despite the likely repercussions. In addition, it serves to lyrically set up the chorus that follows, which is the main job of the pre-chorus.    

Key Points

  • Lines 1 and 2, “Killing me slow, out the window / I’m always waiting for you to be waiting below” function as a cohesive lyrical pair. Their metaphorical qualities cleverly and impactfully convey the intense anticipation and longing Swift feels when not around this person. However, when delving deeper, another even cleverer scenario comes to mind. These lyrics can also be likened to the balcony scene in the tragic love story of Romeo & Juliet, where Juliet awaits Romeo’s arrival outside her window to meet. This cleverly provides the story with more intrigue and depth while remaining in line with its overall message.
  • Line 3, “Devils roll the dice, angels roll their eyes,” is one of the cleverest and most impactful lines in the entire song. Using all aspects of the A.I.D.E. principle, “Devils roll the dice” cleverly conveys the chance Swift is willing to take on her bad boy love interest, while “angels roll their eyes” reflects her going against her better judgement.
  • Line 4, “What doesn’t kill me makes me want you more,” essentially summarizes Swift’s continued intense desire for her love interest despite the relationship’s negative qualities. This effectively sets the stage for Swift’s conflict that follows in the chorus summation. In addition, note that the lyric is also a clever play on “what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.”

Chorus

Narrative Overview

The chorus is composed of two, four-line stanzas and delivers “Cruel Summer’s” lyrical summation. Stanza 1 summarizes both Swift’s exhilaration and pessimism toward the new relationship, while stanza 2 infers that she accepts the uncertainty and the seeming casualness of the relationship, even though it is taking a negative emotional toll on her.  

Stanza 1 Key Points

Stanza 1 is communicated from Swift’s point-of-view, in the present tense, and uses an effective combination of detail devices, emotive lyrics, and clever and common lyricism to convey the summation in an impactful manner.

  • Line 1, “And it’s new, the shape of your body,” cleverly substantiates that it is a new relationship while inferring Swift’s physical attraction to him. Note that this ties in with the “shiny toy” reference in verse 1.
  • Line 2, “It’s blue, the feeling I’ve got,” conveys Swift’s underlying sadness and distress for the relationship’s likely negative outcome. This was previously intimated in the first verse with the lyrics “fever dream” and “shiny toy with a price.”  
  • Line 3, “Ooh, woah-oh,” is a nonsense lyric that serves a variety of purposes: Lyrically, the clever use of the lyric “woah” jibes with the section’s negative connotation, due to its homophonic relation to the lyric “woe” (i.e., “woe” is a word that communicates great sorrow or distress). In addition, “woah” is a highly common nonsense lyric used in a plethora of hit songs, creating mainstream familiarity. Melodically, it foreshadows and subsequently reinforces the song title hook melody that follows in line 4 along with showcasing Swift’s vocal chops (reference the Vocal Melody section of the report for details).
  • Line 4, “It’s a cruel summer,” works hand in hand with the nonsense lyric that precedes it to encapsulate the entire essence of the narrative and the way that Swift feels about the situation – her intense desire for this person and the likely negative outcome. Furthermore, it provides the narrative with heightened depth by tying it into a summer fling scenario.   

Stanza 2 Key Points

Stanza 2 is also delivered from Swift’s point-of-view and communicated using an effective combination of detail devices, emotive lyrics, and clever and common lyricism.

Lines 5 and 6 provide additional information into Swift’s psyche as it pertains to the overall situation. Line 5, “It’s cool, that’s what I tell ‘em,” reiterates her seeming acceptance of the way things are. Line 6, “No rules in breakable heaven,” builds off line 5 by providing additional detail into her mindset. The lyric is a clever way of stating that the relationship is casual, without stringent rules. While it can be great (“heaven”), it is also fragile and can lead to ruin (“breakable”).

Lines 7 and 8 conclude the section on a familiar and catchy note by reiterating the nonsense lyric and song title hook that close out stanza 1.

Verse 2

Narrative Overview

Where verse 1 focused on both the positives and negatives of the new relationship, the verse 2 development veers the story into more overtly negative territory with the relationship’s impending demise. However, the inclusion of the vocoder-processed background vocals, which are a commonality between both verse sections, continues to reinforce Swift’s inner-voiced desire for her love interest.  

Key Points

  • Line 1, “Hang your head low in the glow of the vending machine, I’m not dying,” utilizes an effective combination of imagery and emotion to impactfully depict Swift’s downtrodden yet persevering state. Note the clever tie-in with pre-chorus 1, “what doesn’t kill me makes me want you more.”
  • Line 2, “We say that we’ll just screw it up in these trying times, we’re not trying,” conveys both character’s sentiments concurrently for the first time in the song, providing the narrative with heightened depth. Building off line 1, it communicates two key points:  Surrounding circumstances (“trying times”) might be impacting the relationship’s ability to flourish, and they’re seemingly not trying to make the relationship work.

Pre-Chorus 2

Narrative Overview

Pre-chorus 2 goes against the grain of many hit pop songs by lyrically developing over its pre-chorus 1 counterpart. Lines 1, 2 and 4 provide development, while the reprise of the impactful line 3, “Devils roll the dice, angels roll their eyes,” maintains like-section familiarity and cohesion along with the similar melodies.

While this clever-leaning, A.I.D.E. principle-heavy pre-chorus can be interpreted in a multitude of ways, a likely interpretation following the “relationship heading south” development in the second verse is that Swift is expecting its inevitable end.  

Key Points

  • Line 1, “So cut the headlights, summer’s a knife,” uses all aspects of the A.I.D.E. principle to cleverly convey Swift’s inferred desire for her love interest to “turn the lights out” on the relationship because it’s becoming too difficult for her to bear (“summer’s a knife”). Additionally, the car reference can also be construed as relating to the bridge development, “I’m drunk in the back of the car.”
  • Line 2, the somewhat cliché, “I’m always waiting for you just to cut to the bone,” solidifies line 1’s relationship-ending sentiment while completing the knife/cutting metaphor.
  • Following the reiteration in line 3, line 4 closes out the section with the lyric, “And if I bleed, you’ll be the last to know.” Keeping cohesion with the “knife” and “cutting” references in the preceding lines, it conveys that when he finally does break up with her, and it hurts, that she won’t give him the satisfaction of knowing that it did.

Bridge 1

Narrative Overview

Following chorus 2, the song heads into the first of its two lyrically similar bridge “D” (departure) sections. Along with providing a melodic and instrumental departure in the scope of the song, they uniquely feature intriguing, emotive and vivid lyrical developments. This contrasts from the manner of Swift’s previous narration, providing the story with heightened depth while reiterating pre-established sentiments in a fresh and more direct manner:

  • The relationship’s demise and Swift’s resulting heartbreak.
  • The secretive nature of the relationship.
  • Swift’s continued love for her love interest.
  • Her love interest’s mischievous response to her love proclamation. 

Compared to most of the other sections in the song, the bridge utilizes a greater degree of action and imagery-based lyricism, fewer detail devices (most notably metaphor), and leans more toward the common end of the spectrum as opposed to clever. Note that the latter two were necessary to ensure the listener easily and fully connects with the situations being illustrated. However, the bridge shares the commonality with the other song sections of every line featuring some degree of emotion.  

Stanza 1 Key Points

Stanza 1 is communicated entirely from Swift’s point of view and depicts the aftermath of the breakup.

  • Using all aspects of the A.I.D.E. principle, lines 1 and 2 paint a relatable scene of Swift “coping” with the breakup by self-medicating with alcohol, and the heartbreak she feels. However, note that the omission of specifics relating to the car and bar leave it open for the listener to interpret as they see fit
  • Lines 3 and 4 shift to entirely emotive-based lyricism. They depict the confliction Swift feels about her emotions and her continued desire for her love interest despite the relationship’s demise. Furthermore, line 4 provides an intriguing development that the relationship was secretive, which is open to interpretation by the listener as to why (i.e., he’s cheating on her, she’s sneaking out at night, etc.).

Stanza 2 Key Points

Stanza 2 is communicated entirely from Swift’s point of view, save for the last line, which pertains directly to her love interest. It provides unique insight into the relationship’s history, Swift’s current feelings toward her ex, and her ex’s implied feelings towards her.

  • Lines 5 and 6 follow suit with their line 1 and 2 counterparts by illustrating an actual scenario that Swift has gone through, using all aspects of the A.I.D.E. principle to convey it in a profound manner. Building off the secretive development brought to light in line 4, it illustrates the frequency of the tryst (“every night”), and the impending negative outcome (“seal my fate”). Essentially, this confirms what Swift alluded to all along – the relationship was never going to work.
  • Lines 7, 8 and 9 bring the bridge to an impactful, emotive conclusion by depicting the only actual interaction between the two characters in the story. Lines 7 and 8 powerfully convey Swift’s intense desire and love for this person, while line 9 illustrates his zinger of a response, “he looks up grinnin’ like a devil.” However, it shouldn’t come as a surprise to Swift, as she seemingly understood the nature of the relationship as brought to light in the chorus, “no rules in breakable heaven.” All in all, these lines cleverly sum up what has been alluded to all throughout the song.  

Song Title

Clever/Powerful or Universal/Generic

Song titles fall on a spectrum ranging from unique, clever, attention-grabbing and/or powerful (e.g., “K-POP,” “Rich Men North of Richmond,” and “Paint The Town Red”) to those that possess more of a universal/generic quality (e.g., “Hold Me Closer,” “Like Crazy,” “Thinkin’ Bout Me”).

“Cruel Summer” falls on the attention-grabbing/powerful end of the spectrum through its use of adjective (“cruel”), time period (“summer”), and the intrigue it creates as it pertains to Taylor Swift.

Song Title Word Count

Two-worded song titles have consistently been among the top three most popular in non-hip hop Hot 100 top 10 hits over the past five years, most recently surging to a decade-long high in the first half of 2023. Other notable, diverse, recent hits with two words in their title are “Fast Car,” “Favorite Song” and “Like Crazy.”

Song Title Word Count: Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits (2018 – Q2 2023)

Song Title Appearances and Placement

The title “cruel summer” is featured six times in the song, appearing exclusively in the chorus. The 6-10 song title appearance range has been steadily declining in popularity over the past four years, reaching its lowest level in over a decade in the first half of 2023.

In terms of placement, the chorus is by far the most popular section to feature the song title at 84% of non-hip hop hits over the past five years, with the outro trailing distantly at just under one-third (note that song titles can appear in multiple sections). Furthermore, the title is primly placed at the end of each stanza, where it provides the impactful narrative summation.

Song Title Appearances: Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits (2018 – Q2 2023)

Song Title Placement: Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits (2018 – Q2 2023)

Word Cloud

Benchmark


This section spotlights “Cruel Summer’s” familiarity and standout factors relative to the Hot 100 Top 10, both as a whole and independently of the hip hop genre specifically, in the quarter before the song entered the Hot 100 Top 10 (Q2 2023). The familiarity factors enable “Cruel Summer” to connect with a mainstream audience more easily, while the more atypical factors help it to stand out from the pack.

Of the categories benchmarked in the table below, “Cruel Summer” is in line with 71% of the top characteristics in the overall Hot 100 Top 10 and 75% in non-hip hop hits specifically.
 

“D” Section: A section that provides a pronounced vocal, lyrical, instrumental and/or energy level departure around two-thirds of the way into a song. “D” sections can include bridges, bridge surrogates, and diversified recycled sections.
*Indicates a particular song characteristic falling within a 5% margin of error of the most popular compositional characteristic in a given category

Additional Familiarity & Standout Factors

In addition to the commonalities shown in the chart above, other factors that contributed to “Cruel Summer’s” ability to easily connect with mainstream audiences include its K.I.S.S. ME melodies (Keep It Simple, Singable and Memorable), catchy vocal hooks, strong, effective rhymes, logical, easy-to-follow structure, and engaging, relatable subject matter, to name a few.

Conversely, a few notable places where the song stood out among its contemporaries is its inclusion of two bridge sections as opposed to one, super short verse sections, relatively uncommon vocoder hook, and abundance of clever, metaphorical lyrics.

Back to Top

Sample Report: abcdefu Deconstructed

Back to Top

About This Report


PRO Edition

Hit Songs Deconstructed reports take a deep dive into the what, how, and why behind a current chart-topping hit. These exceptionally comprehensive reports feature a combination of impartial data and insightful analysis illustrated through charts, graphs, and notation.

Essentials Edition

Based on the Hit Songs Deconstructed PRO report, Essentials delivers high-level takeaways through insightful section-by-section analysis illustrated with charts, graphs and commentary, providing an in-depth understanding of the hit songwriting and production techniques involved in crafting the song.

Download Feel It Still Essentials as a PDF >>

abcdefu Deconstructed


abcdefu is the breakout hit for Atlantic recording artist and teen sensation GAYLE. Co-written by Taylor Rutherfurd (aka GAYLE), Dave Pittenger, and Sara Davis and produced by Pete Nappi, this scathing breakup anthem has gone viral since its release in the summer of 2021, turning GAYLE into a household name both in the United States and abroad.

abcdefu possesses a mixture of both the familiar and the unique among its Hot 100 Top 10 contemporaries, allowing listeners to easily connect with the song while simultaneously standing out from the pack.

On the familiar side are hit songwriting and production best practices, such as adhering to HSD’s K.I.S.S. ME principle (keep it simple, singable and memorable); using clever hook foreshadowing and reinforcement techniques to bolster familiarity and catchiness while maintaining interest; and keeping the song on the shorter end of the spectrum – namely under the three-minute mark – to name just a few of many. The song also achieves strong prosody between the lyrics, vocals and music to create a unified vibe and heighten the listener’s emotional connection with the song.

However, it is some of the song’s unique and atypical characteristics that help it to stand out from the pack. Perhaps most notable is its clever, shouted “A-B-C-D-E-F-U” song title hook, which provides the defiant summation of the narrative in an A.P.M. (audience participation moment) manner that is primed for a live setting. In addition, the song possesses atypical structural characteristics such as kicking off with the chorus as opposed to the far more popular intro, the omission of a “D” (departure) section, such as a bridge, and having shorter than normal chorus lengths. And lyrically, the song goes against the grain by changing up some of the chorus lyrics, a practice that is largely unheard of in mainstream hits. However, each decision is made with intent and purpose, and serves the song perfectly.

Since its release, abcdefu has achieved great success in an array of mediums and charts, including going viral on the popular app TikTok, peaking at #3 on the Billboard Hot 100, topping the Billboard Global 200, and reaching the Top 10 in over 30 countries across the globe. Additionally, subsequent remixes featuring varying versions of the song, from “nicer” to “chill” to “angrier,” helped to bolster its visibility and reach.

In this report, we’ll be analyzing the factors that contributed to this success, including the song’s structure, vocal melody and production, instrumental arrangement, lyrics, energy, and much more.

Video Deconstruction


This video deconstruction compliments the PRO report by taking you through the song section-by-section with a focus on hooks, vocal melody, vocal production, narrative, accompaniment, energy, influences, and much more. Each section is visualized with its arrangement in Logic Pro X.


At a Glance


Artist: GAYLE
Song: abcdefu
Songwriters: GAYLE, Dave Pittenger, Sara Davis
Producers: Pete Nappi
Mastering Engineer: Daniel Rowland
Mixer: Pete Nappi
Record Label: Atlantic
Primary Genre: Rock
Influences: Alt/Indie, Pop, Punk, Rock
Length: 2:47
Form: B-A-PC-B-VB-A-PC-B-VB-B
Key: E Major
Tempo: 61 BPM
First Chorus: Kickoff (0:00)
Electronic vs. Acoustic Instrumentation: Primarily Electronic
Prominent Instruments: Bass (Synth), Claps, Drums/Percussion (All), Drums/Percussion (Primarily Electronic), Guitar (Acoustic), Guitar (Electric), Synth (Non-Bass)
Primary Lyrical Themes: Love/Relationships
Title Appearances: abcdefu appears 5 times in the song

Section Abbreviation Key

A=Verse
PC=Pre-Chorus
B=Chorus
VB=Vocal Break

Music notation and lyric excerpts are reproduced here under Fair Use terms, for the purposes of commentary and criticism.


Overview, Highlights & Takeaways


Hooks and Motifs

KEY
A=Verse | B=Chorus | PC=Pre-Chorus | VB=Vocal Break
Number: Denotes the number of times that a particular hook/motif appears within a section

abcdefu’s Hook Arrangement

abcdefu’s first hook is heard right at the top of the song in chorus 1. Here, the listener is immediately “hooked” into the song with the chorus melody hook, which delivers the scathing lyrics with a simple, repetitive pattern that is reminiscent of popular nursery rhymes (see the vocal melody section of the report for more details).

Following the chorus, the listener gets a hook respite in the verse and pre-chorus sections, which is highly characteristic of mainstream hits. However, these two sections feature motifs that subtly reinforce and foreshadow other key hooks in the song, which makes abcdefu even more cohesive, catchy and memorable. The 1-3-7 verse motif subtly reinforces the 1-3-1 and 1-3-7 melodies heard throughout the chorus, and the pre-chorus melody is highly similar to the “nah” nonsense hook melody heard in the vocal break post-choruses.

Following the pre-chorus, the song heads into chorus 2, which has been developed over chorus 1 to include the first instance of the song-defining “A-B-C-D-E-F-U” song title hook. Cleverly set up by the “so let me spell it out” lyric at the end of the pre-chorus, the hook stands out through its quasi-sung/shouted A.M.P. (alternating melodic pattern) delivery over a partial accompaniment pull S.I.A. (section impact accentuator). The ensuing vocal break post-chorus then reinforces the song title hook along with the first instance of the aformentioned “nah” nonsense hook, which cleverly bolsters the summation’s dismissive tone through its subtle resemblance to Steam’s 1969 hit, Na Na Hey Hey Kiss Him Goodbye.

Verse 2 and pre-chorus 2 then fall in line with their first occurrence counterparts, providing hook respites while subtly reinforcing hook melodies heard previously in the song. The last three sections of the song – chorus 3, vocal break post-chorus 2 and chorus 4 – all reinforce their previous counterpart’s hooks, albeit with some modified qualities to prevent redundancy. Chorus 3 changes up some of the lyrics (reference the narrative section of the report for details); vocal break post-chorus 2 is twice the length of its first occurrence counterpart and features a denser arrangement and a slight lyrical changeup; and chorus 4 breaks down to a sparse arrangement along with some slight melodic differences compared to the other choruses.

Together, the effective combination of hook foreshadowing, reinforcement, modification and respites creates a highly catchy and memorable listening experience that never wears out its welcome.

Chorus Melody Hook

Chorus Melody Hook Motif

Song Title Hook

Nonsense Lyric Hook

Nonsense Lyric Hook Foreshadowing

Structure: Overview

abcdefu possesses both structural commonalities and differences compared to recent non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits. On the more common side are its two, easy-to-follow, verse – pre-chorus – chorus – vocal break post-chorus sectional progressions; allocating the greatest amount of time in the song to the chorus; and its short, under three-minute song length, to name a few.

Balancing out its more familiar qualities are unique characteristics such as its omission of popular sections including the intro, “D” section and outro; immediately kicking off with the chorus as opposed to an intro; and featuring shorter than average choruses. While atypical, these decisions were all strategic choices made by the writers and producers.

Genres & Influences: Overview

abcdefu is a rock song with a combination of pop, punk and alt/indie influences.

Instrumentation & Arrangement: Overview

abcdefu features an expertly crafted instrumental arrangement that achieves a lot in its short runtime. At its heart is a strategic assortment of mix elements including electronic and acoustic drums and percussion, electric and acoustic guitars, electric and synth basses, keys, and a host of effects. Together, along with their varying timbres, textures and patterns, they create an engaging sound pallet that is rooted in “traditional” guitar-driven rock while simultaneously appealing to a modern pop audience.

But perhaps most notable is the methodical manner in that the arrangement unfolds over the course of the song. In addition to creating an effective balance of engagement and familiarity across sections, which is the hallmark of a strong arrangement, the manner in that it supports the vocals and lyrics to create effective prosody and heighten the listener’s emotional connection with the song is its true brilliance.

From the solo guitar bookending chorus arrangements that support GAYLE’s subdued delivery of the scathing lyrics, to the dense, high-energy mid-song chorus payoffs that put the chorus lyrics in a new angrier context along with the shouted gang vocals, to the timbral thinning of the acoustic guitar-driven pre-chorus 1 arrangement that effectively sets up the ensuing chorus along with the higher-register vocals, these accompaniment shifts provide abcdefu with heightened emotional dimension that deepens the listener’s connection with the song, and the artist.

Energy: Overview

abcdefu progresses through two energy level “waves.” Each flows from low to high, with peaks in the vocal break post-choruses, save for the lower energy “wind down” fourth chorus at the end. It features an effective combination gradual and pronounced energy shifts, complimenting loudness shifts, tradeoffs between power and momentum, and impactful S.I.A.s (section impact accentuators), all of which come together to create an engaging listening experience that keeps the listener locked in from start to finish.

Harmony: Overview

abcdefu features on chord progression that is kept interesting through a variety of delivery styles throughout the song.

Progression 1: Variation 1a (Chorus 1, Verse 1 (Stz. 1))

E5 – G#5 – C#5 – A5

Vocal Production: Overview
Lead Vocal Gender

abcdefu features a solo female lead vocal from GAYLE. Generally hovering between one-quarter and one-third of non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits over the past five years, solo female leads have been trading off with solo male leads for top billing up until 2021, when they tied and slightly trailed all-male duet/group vocals.

Lead Vocal Gender in Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2017 – 2021

Lead Vocal Delivery

abcdefu features an exclusively sung lead vocal delivery. Not surprisingly, non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits that feature exclusively sung lead vocals have by far been the most popular over the past five years and beyond, with 70% of songs in 2021.

Lead Vocal Delivery in Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2017 – 2021

Background Vocals

In addition to the lead, abcdefu features a host of background vocals including harmonies, unison doubles, sung adlibs, and shouted gang vocals.

Effects & Processing

abcdefu features minimal vocal effects and processing, including reverb, delay and autotune, all of which maintain an intimate vibe while adhering to mainstream vocal production standards.

Vocal Delivery Arrangement Overview

Lead: Female (GAYLE): GAYLE’s lead vocal
BGV 1: Female (Unison Double): Background vocal doubles in unison with the lead
BGV 2: Female (Lead Harmony): Background vocal that harmonizes with the lead on different pitches
BGV 3: Female (Lead Gang Vocals): Background vocals that are tracked many times to create a large “crowd” effect
BGV 4: Female (Independent Backgrounds): Background vocals featured independently from the lead
BGV 5: Female (Independent GAYLE): Lead vocals that are independent embellishments

Key

BGV: Background vocals
S: Sung
SH: Shouted
/: Separates stanzas in sections where a certain vocal type occurs in only one stanza

Vocal Melody: Overview
Sectional Melodic Part Structure: At-A-Glance

Verse 1

Verse 2

Pre-Chorus

Chorus

*Note that while choruses 1 and 4 feature slight variations melodically, chorus 2 is most indicative of the chorus melody, with the differences noted in the analysis below

Vocal Break

Sectional Melodic Flow: At-A-Glance

Verse 1

Verse 2

Pre-Chorus

Chorus 2

Vocal Break

Rhymes: Overview

abcdefu features expert use of rhymes and other connection accentuators that ensure the song remains lingering in the listener’s head long after it ends. Among them are logically unfolding end-of-line rhyme schemes, strategically placed internal rhymes, double and triple rhymes, alliteration, repetitive lyrics, and the mirroring between rhyme schemes, syllabic structure and melodic structure to heighten cohesion and connectability.

At-A-Glance: End-Of-Line Rhymes Section By Section

Key
A, B & C: End-of-line rhymes
X: Non-rhymes
Lyrics: The primary rhyme at the end of each line
Colors and rhyme schemes are unique to each section

Narrative: Overview

abcdefu is a love/relationships-themed song about a protagonist (GAYLE) who experiences a teenage heartbreak and is deeply angered by her ex’s behavior following the breakup. Her feelings are succinctly summarized with the clever song title hook “A-B-C-D-E-F-U,” a play on the alphabet that both insults her ex’s intelligence while telling them off in a particularly scathing and memorable manner.

Throughout the song, a host of expert lyrical techniques are employed that go both with and against the grain. Among the more common are delivering the relatable lyrics in a conversational manner, using an effective balance of common and clever lyricism, incorporating aspects of the A.I.D.E. principle (action, imagery, detail devices, emotion) to heighten interest, featuring a nonsense lyric hook, and the logical unfolding of lines both within and across sections, to name just a few.

Conversely, the song goes against the grain most notably with its chorus. Among its atypical chorus qualities are providing the listener with the summation at the top of the song before the backstory is established (i.e. having the chorus appear before the first verse), using ample profanity (most notably in the song title hook), and changing up the chorus lyrics, which is rarely done. However, all of these decisions were done with an intent and purpose that served the song perfectly.

Additionally, abcdefu is also a perfect example of “writing what you know.” The lyrics pertain to GAYLE’s own personal experiences with heartbreak, which bolstered her ability to deliver the song in a compelling manner and heighten its connection with her teen girl fanbase.

Chorus 1

Verse 1

Pre-Choruses

Choruses 2 – 4

Vocal Breaks

Verse 2

Song Title: Overview

Song titles fall on a spectrum ranging from unique, clever, attention-grabbing and/or powerful (e.g. 712PM, N95, and Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)), to those that possess more of a universal/generic quality (e.g. First Class, I Like You (A Happier Song) and Woman).

abcdefu leans heavily toward the attention-grabbing end of the spectrum due to its reference to the English alphabet as well as the clever twist on a common phrase, “F-you.” This instantly piques the listener’s curiosity concerning the song’s narrative, while functioning as an incredibly catchy and memorable song-title hook.

Song Structure


Overview

abcdefu possesses both structural commonalities and differences compared to recent non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits. On the more common side are its two, easy-to-follow, verse – pre-chorus – chorus – vocal break post-chorus sectional progressions; allocating the greatest amount of time in the song to the chorus; and its short, under three-minute song length, to name a few.

Balancing out its more familiar qualities are unique characteristics such as its omission of popular sections including the intro, “D” section and outro; immediately kicking off with the chorus as opposed to an intro; and featuring shorter than average choruses. While atypical, these decisions were all strategic choices made by the writers and producers.

Sections

abcdefu contains 10 sections in its framework:

  • Two verse sections
  • Two pre-chorus sections
  • Four chorus sections
  • Two vocal break post-chorus sections

Song Section Classifications

Post-Chorus Section Classification

A post-chorus is the classification of a song section that directly follows the chorus and functions as an additional “hook center” in the song’s framework. abcdefu’s post-chorus is the vocal break following choruses 2 and 3. It features a unique hook pairing between the fresh but familiar nonsense hook, which references the pre-chorus melody, and the song-defining “A-B-C-D-E-F-U” song title hook.

While post-choruses have generally been popular in non-hip hop Top 10 hits over the past decade (typically being used in half of songs or more), their use notably dropped in 2021 to just 38% of songs. Among post-chorus sections, the vocal break has been most popular in the last four out of five years, being used in roughly one-quarter of non-hip hop hits in 2021.

Post-Chorus Sections in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2021

Structural Anomalies

Chorus as the First Section

abcdefu notably goes against the grain of most non-hip hop hits by immediately kicking off with the chorus. In fact, it was one of only two songs in the first quarter of 2022 that did so, the other being We Don’t Talk About Bruno, from a Disney film.

While hitting the listener with the song’s primary “hook center” early on certainly has its benefits, a possible detriment in today’s day and age is that the listener might get their fill and hit the skip button before reaching the 30-second mark, which is where the song counts as a stream. However, a clever way that abcdefu skirts this issue is by saving both its song-defining, shouted “A-B-C-D-E-F-U” song title hook and high-energy payoff for later in the song.

First Section in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2017-2021

Omission of a “D” Section

Another area where abcdefu notably goes against the grain is by omitting a bridge or bridge surrogate “D” (departure) section, which has historically been very popular among non-hip hop Top 10 hits (81%-87% of songs over the past five years). However, there is arguably enough variety throughout the song to effectively keep the listener engaged from start to finish, and by omitting the “D” section it keeps the song on the shorter end of the spectrum.

Use Of A “D” Section in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2017-2021

Form

abcdefu kicks off with the chorus followed by two verse – pre-chorus – chorus – vocal break sectional progressions. Its like-sections (i.e., verse 1 and verse 2) possess a balance of similarities and differences that keep things cohesive yet interesting as the song progresses. Following these two sectional progressions, a final chorus bookends the song on a fresh but familiar note.

Time and Percent into the Song When Core Sections Occur

abcdefu

Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 (2021)

*Data excludes Taylor Swift’s 10-minute long All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)

Save for abcdefu’s first verse, which has its arrival time on par with the Top 10 average, the time and percent into the song when its core sections occur is notably different. This is due in part to the song kicking off with the chorus, the omission of a “D” section, and its atypically long 32 second first verse, all of which alter its structural ordering from the norm.

 

Song & Section Length

Song Length

abcdefu clocks in at 2:47. While this is notably shorter than the 2021 Top 10 average of 3:18, it is in-line with the rise in songs landing under the three-minute mark, which edged-out the 3:00-3:29 range to become most popular in 2021.

Its short length is due in part to the omission of common song sections, like an intro, “D” section and outro, and its shorter-than-typical section lengths.

Song Length Ranges of Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2017 – 2021

Section Length

Section lengths in abcdefu are both typical and atypical of non-hip hop Top 10 hits. On the typical side are its pre-chorus and second vocal break post-chorus, which are right in-line with 2021 averages. However, its choruses are seven-seconds shorter; its first vocal break is half the length of the second, functioning more as a “tease” than a fully developed section; and its two verses are both notably longer and shorter than the 27 second average, landing at 32 seconds and 16 seconds, respectively.

Total Section Breakdown

*Note that numbers may be rounded, resulting in slightly more or less than 100% of the song’s total composition

As is commonly the case with non-hip hop hits, abcdefu allocates the most time to the chorus, comprising 38% of its total composition. The verse follows at 29%, and the pre-chorus and vocal break round things out at 19% and 14% respectively.

Compared to the 2021 non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 average, abcdefu allocates more time to the pre-chorus and chorus, and essentially equal amounts of time to the verse and vocal break.

abcdefu / 2021 Hot 100 Top 10 Average Time Allocation

  • Verse: 29% / 30%
  • Pre-Chorus: 19% / 15%
  • Chorus: 38% / 35%
  • Vocal Break: 14% / 14%

Tempo & Key

Tempo

abcdefu sits at 61 BPM, 35 BPM slower than the 2021 non-hip hop Top 10 average of 96 BPM. The 60-69 BPM range was the fifth most popular tempo range of 2021, bouncing back after a drop in popularity in 2020. Some of the songs that fell into this tempo range in 2021 include Good Days, Need To Know, Wasted On You and Your Power, among others.

Tempo Range in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2017 – 2021 (Top 5)

Key

abcdefu is in the key of E major. While major keys have been most popular among non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits since 2019, they’ve been steadily declining and were neck-and-neck with minor keys in 2021.

Major vs. Minor Keys in Non-Hip Hop Hot 100 Top 10 Hits: 2017 – 2021



Energy & Dynamics


Energy Arrangement

abcdefu progresses through two energy level “waves.” Each flows from low to high, with peaks in the vocal break post-choruses, save for the lower energy “wind down” fourth chorus at the end. It features an effective combination of gradual and pronounced energy shifts, complimenting loudness shifts, tradeoffs between power and momentum, and impactful S.I.A.s (section impact accentuators), all of which come together to create an engaging listening experience that keeps the listener locked in from start to finish.

Key
Wave:
Indicates cross-sectional energy level flow from low to high
S.I.A. (Section Impact Accentuator): A transitional technique that heightens engagement through an accompaniment pull (full or partial), effect (riser, downlifter, etc.) and/or fill

Loudness

abcdefu features an effective balance of both gradual and dynamic loudness shifts that closely mirror its energy flow. The most notable leaps occur leading into choruses 2 and 4, the first helping to maximize the chorus 2 high-energy payoff, and the second aiding in the chorus 4 wind-down at the end of the song.

Note that all LUFS levels in the song are fairly in line with the industry standard of a mastered mainstream hit.

Energy: Section By Section

Wave 1: Chorus 1 – Vocal Break 1 (VB1)

Chorus 1 (B1)

Chorus 1 features the second-lowest overall energy in the entire song, providing room for growth in subsequent sections. It’s comprised of GAYLE’s mainly solo sung vocal and sixteenth-note driven electric guitar, the latter providing a subtle sense of forward motion in lieu of drums and bass.

S.I.A. #1

At the end of the chorus, there is one – albeit relatively subtle – burst of energy, put into effect by the tension-heightening riser/downlifter sound effects, along with the shouted group delivery of the definitive “f**k off” lyric. Together, these energy-heightening elements bolster engagement leading into the ensuing verse.

Verse 1 (A1)

Verse 1 notably kicks up the song’s energy over the preceding chorus. The addition of drums, along with GAYLE’s rhythmic vocal delivery, locks the listener into a simmering groove, while the addition of low-octave guitar and bass provide low-end power that was missing from the chorus.

Pre-Chorus 1 (PC1)

The notably changed-up pre-chorus results in a slight decrease in energy compared to the preceding verse. However, this variation is minimal due to the tradeoff in energy-affecting qualities – namely power vs. momentum. While the omission of the verse’s sub-bass and electric guitar thin out the sound, the vibrant acoustic guitar strumming along with the eighth-note kick pattern create a heightened degree of momentum. This is bolstered by GAYLE’s higher-range and more animated vocal delivery, which further heightens excitement and anticipation leading into the ensuing chorus.

S.I.A. #2

The pre-chorus ends with all the elements abruptly pulled from the mix. In their place, the tension-heightening riser/downlifter transitional effect returns, along with high-energy gang vocals that accentuate the song title hook and set up the ensuing chorus for maximum impact.

Chorus 2 (B2)

Chorus 2 notably kicks up the song’s energy right from the start. This is due in part to the more dense and powerful instrumental arrangement, and the addition of shouted gang vocals that double GAYLE’s lead. Together, along with the notable jump in loudness from -10.5 to -7 LUFS, they provide the listener with the song’s first high-energy “payoff,” framing the chorus lyrics in a new, angrier and more powerful context compared to the first time around.

Vocal Break 1 (VB1)

With the core arrangement of the chorus remaining in effect, the vocal break post-chorus kicks energy up another notch through the incorporation of the sixteenth-note-driven palm-muted distorted electric guitar from the verse and the newly added driving hi hat. Together, along with the shouted/sung-hybrid vocal hooks, they take abcdefu’s energy to its first peak.

S.I.A. #3

At the end of the vocal break, a one-beat partial accompaniment pull S.I.A. is implemented, providing subtle separation between the energetic vocal break post-chorus and verse arrangements. This in turn bolsters the arrival of the verse 2 groove while accentuating the “f-u” of the song title hook.

Wave 2: Verse 2 (A2) – Chorus 4 (B4)

Verse 2 (A2) Bars 1-2

Following the energy peak in the vocal break post-chorus, abcdefu’s energy is brought back down in the ensuing verse through a more intimate lead vocal and the omission of the distorted melodic guitar and driving open hi hats. However, while the decrease in loudness from -7.5 to -10.5 is quite pronounced, the overall cross-section energy reduction is fairly minimal, considering its more developed, driving qualities compared to its verse 1 counterpart. Most notable is the addition of closed hi-hat, which provides the section with increased drive, and the brighter, more reverberant snare, which results in a bigger sound (reference the Music & Instruments section of the report for details).

S.I.A. #4

Toward the end of bar 2, the first of abcdefu’s two full accompaniment pull S.I.A.s is implemented for 1.5 beats. This heightens engagement through a brief break in momentum that highlights the lyric “you couldn’t take it.”

Pre-Chorus 2 (PC2)

In contrast to pre-chorus 1, the first-half of pre-chorus 2 maintains much of the accompaniment from the verse. This, along with the addition of momentum-driving elements such as the vibrantly strummed acoustic guitar and melodic electric guitar, and the omission of power elements like the sub-bass, results in a fairly even energy tradeoff between sections.

However, this all changes in the second half of the section, when the pre-chorus reverts to the more thinned-out qualities of its pre-chorus 1 counterpart. In addition to providing arrangement contrast against the ensuing chorus, it also provides a necessary energy contrast to help bolster its impact.

S.I.A. #5

At the end of the second pre-chorus, the downlifter and riser effects are once again employed, creating a familiar S.I.A. leading into chorus 3. However, this S.I.A. does not feature an accompaniment pull, instead maintaining the pre-chorus arrangement along with a sped-up kick to further heighten momentum leading into the chorus.

Chorus 3 (B3)

Like it’s chorus 2 counterpart, chorus 3 provides a notable leap in energy over the pre-chorus due to its dense and powerful arrangement. However, its energy is a touch higher this time around due to the inclusion of additional gang vocal layers, guitar, bass and hats.

Vocal Break 2 (VB2)

Vocal break 2 takes abcdefu’s energy and loudness to its grand peak. This is due to the inclusion of louder gang vocals and offbeat guitar accents on top of the high-energy chorus 3 accompaniment.

Chorus 4 (B4)

Following the climactic vocal break post-chorus, the final chorus of abcdefu does a full 180 and drops energy to its lowest level in the song. This is due in part to its stripped back instrumental arrangement – consisting solely of a chorused/filtered melodic guitar pattern – and GAYLE’s more reserved delivery, omitting the high-energy gang vocal accompaniment. Complimenting this is a drastic reduction in loudness, leaping from -6 in the vocal break (the loudest in the song) to -15.5 (the lowest in the song). This bookends the song on a familiar note, energetically concluding it similar to chorus 1.

S.I.A. #6

This full accompaniment pull S.I.A. pulls the guitar from the mix, leaving only GAYLE’s final rendition of the final “you can all f**k off” lyric lingering in the listener’s head at the conclusion of the song.



Genres & Influences


Overview

abcdefu is a rock song with a combination of pop, punk and alt/indie influences.

Genres & Influence Blend

Key
X: The influence appears prominently within the stanza and/or section
x: The influence appears minimally within the stanza and/or section

Rock

abcdefu’s primary genre is rock, which is prominent throughout the entire song. While it possesses both notable rock and pop qualities, it leans more toward the rock end of the spectrum due in part to its prominent use of distorted electric guitar and a rock-oriented progression, GAYLE’s combination of snarling and exasperated vocal deliveries, and scathing lyrics to boot.

Pop

abcdefu’s pop influence is due to its notable mainstream-friendly qualities including its K.I.S.S. ME (keep it simple, singable, and memorable) melodies, infectious vocal hooks, easy-to-follow-structure, relatable lyrical theme, and instrumentation such as electronic drums and riser/downlifter transitional effects.

Punk

While not as punk as more traditional, up-tempo punk songs by the likes of The Sex Pistols, The Clash and The Ramones, abcdefu does have a notable underlying punk attitude. This is due to the combination of the rawness of the electric guitar timbre and its accompanying pattern, the snarling and exasperated vocals, and the profanity-laced lyrics.

Alt/Indie

abcdefu features a minimal alt/indie influence that’s present from the second chorus through the end of the song. It’s put into effect exclusively by some of the guitars, including the alternating melodic pattern heard in the choruses and vocal break post-choruses, and the reverb-drenched guitar accents heard in the second verse and second vocal break post-chorus.

Blending In & Standing Out

abcdefu’s expert fusion of rock, pop, punk and alt/indie influences enabled it to effectively blend in and stand out in today’s mainstream music scene.

On the familiar side is its notable pop influence, which not surprisingly was present in all songs in 2021 and in years prior. While rock as a primary genre has been scarce, as an influence it was notably more popular, present in one-third of non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits in 2021. Among the diverse group of Top 10s that feature a rock influence in varying degrees of prominence are Glass Animals’ Heat Waves, Gabby Barrett’s I Hope, 24K Goldn and iann dior’s Mood, and perhaps most notably, Olivia Rodrigo’s Good 4 U.

And speaking of Good 4 U, both songs also share the commonality of the far less popular alt/indie and punk influences. Alt/indie has generally hovered around 13% of songs on average over the past five years, and punk has generally been non-existent. In addition to shaping abcdefu’s sound and vibe, these influences also helped it stand out among its mainstream contemporaries, while the more popular pop and rock influences enabled it to sound familiar and more easily connect.

Rock as a Primary Genre in the Hot 100 Top 10: 2017 – 2021

Influences in the Hot 100 Top 10: 2017 – 2021 (Outside the Hip Hop/Rap Primary Genre)



Music & Instruments


Overview

abcdefu features an expertly crafted instrumental arrangement that achieves a lot in its short runtime. At its heart is a strategic assortment of mix elements including electronic and acoustic drums and percussion, electric and acoustic guitars, electric and synth basses, keys, and a host of effects. Together, along with their varying timbres, textures and patterns, they create an engaging sound pallet that is rooted in “traditional” guitar-driven rock while simultaneously appealing to a modern pop audience.

But perhaps most notable is the methodical manner in that the arrangement unfolds over the course of the song. In addition to creating an effective balance of engagement and familiarity across sections, which is the hallmark of a strong arrangement, the manner in that it supports the vocals and lyrics to create effective prosody and heighten the listener’s emotional connection with the song is its true brilliance.

From the solo guitar bookending chorus arrangements that support GAYLE’s subdued delivery of the scathing lyrics, to the dense, high-energy mid-song chorus payoffs that put the chorus lyrics in a new angrier context along with the shouted gang vocals, to the timbral thinning of the acoustic guitar-driven pre-chorus 1 arrangement that effectively sets up the ensuing chorus along with the higher-register vocals, these accompaniment shifts provide abcdefu with heightened emotional dimension that deepens the listener’s connection with the song, and the artist.

*Click image to enlarge

Primary Instruments


Guitar

Main Electric Guitar 1

The main electric guitar used in abcdefu is introduced in the first chorus and then returns in every section save for pre-chorus 1 and choruses 2 and 4. It plays a palm-muted sixteenth-note pattern, is double tracked with hard left and right panning, and is treated with distortion, providing the song with its raw rock grit.

Main Electric Guitar 2 (Octave Double)

This guitar is processed similarly to the main electric guitar and plays the same pattern, albeit an octave below. It is featured in the same sections as the main electric guitar save for the first chorus, providing additional low-end texture and density to the mix.

Melodic Electric Guitar 1 (Distorted)

This distorted electric guitar plays a unique sixteenth-note alternating melodic pattern exclusively in choruses 2 and 3 and in their ensuing vocal breaks. Double tracked and panned hard left and right to surround the listener, its inclusion both heightens interest and forward motion, helping the song’s main “hook centers” to further stand out and connect against the surrounding sections.

Melodic Electric Guitar 2 (Chorused/Filtered)

This guitar plays the same pattern as melodic electric guitar 1, albeit with less distortion and the addition of a chorus/filtering effect. It provides a unique texture to the last four sections of the song starting in pre-chorus 2 and is heard most audibly in chorus 4 due to the sparseness of the arrangement.

Muted Electric Guitar

Despite being underneath the thick guitar layers, the subtle plucking of the muted guitar adds an extra attack to the guitar rhythms in vocal break 1.

Electric Guitar Accents

Compared to the other electric guitars in the song, this one is notably cleaner, higher-voiced and processed with copious reverb and delay. It adds stabs on the off-beats, providing a unique rhythmic quality and texture to the second half of verse 2 through the first half of pre-chorus 2 and the entirety of vocal break 2.

Acoustic Guitar

Acoustic guitar is featured solely in the pre-choruses. Its lighter, brighter texture provides engaging contrast against the surrounding sections, helping the denser and more energetic choruses to further stand out and connect. It features slight high-pass filtering to enhance the lighter texture, and is double tracked and panned hard left and right.

Synths

Vintage Synth

This synth possesses a distinct vintage quality with its low-passed timbre and warbling tape emulator sound. It provides unique harmonic support in all sections save for choruses 1, 2 and 4 and the first stanza of verse 1.

Keys

Piano (Acoustic)

Acoustic piano appears in the third chorus and subsequent vocal break, providing high-pitched melodic accents to the dense arrangement. While it is featured fairly low in the mix, it cuts through with its panning and subtle grittiness, due in part to some saturation processing.

Bass

Electric Bass

The electric bass is initially heard in the first verse, and is present in all subsequent sections, save for choruses 2 and 4 and vocal break 1. It provides a sixteenth-note pulse treated with slight distortion that allows it to stand out from the other low-end layers, while also blending with the main electric guitar.

Synth Sub-Bass

The synth sub-bass initially appears sustaining underneath the electric bass in verse 1, and is present in every subsequent section, save for the pre-choruses and chorus 4. It adds an additional layer that fills out and thickens the low end of the arrangement.

Synth Fuzz Bass

The synth fuzz bass is heard in choruses 2 and 3 and the subsequent vocal breaks. It heightens the low end with a gritty texture, keeping the song rooted in a dark tonality and adding more emphasis to these hook-based sections.

Drums/Percussion

Kick 1 (Electronic)

Kick 1 is a thick electronic sample, making its first appearance in verse 1 and remaining in effect until chorus 4. It performs a busy pattern that drives the rhythmic motion of the song, with a strong attack and ample compression that allows it to cut through the mix.

Tight Snare (Electronic)

Heard exclusively in the first verse, the tight snare solidifies the backbeat with a dry, thick distorted timbre that is layered with the bright claps to further bolster the attack and provide punch to the mix.

Tight Reverberant Snare (Electronic)

Directly related to the tight snare, the tight reverberant snare is the same sample but processed with copious reverb, beginning in the second verse and heard through the first half of pre-chorus 2. The additional reverb enhances the density and energy of the section, while providing a cohesive thread between the two snare tones.

Large Reverberant Snare (Electronic)

The large reverberant snare is present in choruses 2 and 3 and the ensuing vocal breaks. Drenched in reverb, it provides these “hook centers” with a bigger, more epic sound that helps to bolster their impact.

Thin Snare (Electronic)

This thin, dry snare adds slight rhythmic variation to the second chorus and first vocal break.

Reversed Snare (Electronic)

Acting as a short riser, the reversed snare heightens engagement leading into the third chorus.

Claps 1 (Filtered-Electronic)

Featured solely in the first pre-chorus, the filtered claps replace the snare of the preceding verse to help heighten cross-section engagement leading into the ensuing chorus.

Claps 2 (Bright-Electronic)

The unfiltered version of claps 1, these brighter, more piercing claps are layered with the tight snare and tight reverberant snare, and are prominently featured in the second half of pre-chorus 2.

Open Hi Hat (Acoustic)

The open hi hat adds an acoustic texture that accentuates the song’s rock feel with a driving rhythm on the off-beats in the vocal breaks and third chorus.

Closed Hi Hat (Electronic)

This hi hat possesses a thin, gritty tone that enhances the kick drum pattern in the second and third choruses and the ensuing vocal breaks.

Closed Hi Hat (Acoustic)

Similar to the open hi hat, this closed hi hat provides an acoustic texture with a sixteenth-note driving rhythm. It is present from the second verse through the first half of the second pre-chorus, and returns in the third chorus and second vocal break.

Reversed Hi Hat (Acoustic)

This reversed version of the closed acoustic hi hat functions as a transitional element leading most notably into the second pre-chorus as well as the second vocal break post-chorus.

Crash Cymbal (Acoustic)

The crash cymbal bolsters the arrival of choruses 2 and 3 and vocal breaks 1 and 2 with a bright, piercing impact.

Shaker (Electronic)

Pitch and formant-shifted down, the shaker provides an underlying rustle effect that enhances the gritty nature of the song in the second verse and first half of the second pre-chorus.

Effects

Downlifter

The downlifter is a distorted triangle wave that is gradually pitch shifted down to heighten engagement between sections.

Digital Riser

Paired with the downlifter, the riser is constructed similarly, pitch shifting upwards to create a rising effect. With an infusion of white noise and distortion, the two combine to heighten engagement and interest between sections.

Synth Impact SFX

Drenched in reverb, this bright synth with a “woo”-type characteristic enhances the impact of the downbeat of choruses 2 and 3, vocal break 1 and verse 2.

Reversed SFX

This sound effect is a bright synth texture used as a transitional riser leading into the first pre-chorus.

Click SFX

This high-pitched, percussive sample subtly bolsters the full accompaniment pull S.I.A. (section impact accentuator) and exposed vocal in the second verse.

Chordal Riser

The chordal riser provides engaging harmonic support coming out of the accompaniment pull in verse 2 and leading into pre-chorus 2. Created by reversing a synth pad, it is treated with a copious amount of reverb that adds a touch of depth to contrast from the many dry, front-and-center textures of the song.

Chordal Impact

Complementing the chordal riser, the chordal impact is a reverb-drenched synth that accentuates the second half of verse 2 and the second pre-chorus.

Music & Instruments: Section By Section


Chorus 1 (0:00 – 0:17)
Chord Progression: E5 – G#5 – C#5 – A5 (E major: I-V/vi-vi-IV)

*Note that this chord progression is repeated throughout the song. For additional details reference the Harmonic Progressions section of the report.

Chorus 1 kicks abcdefu off in a sparse manner, with a palm-muted, sixteenth-note-driven distorted electric guitar providing the sole accompaniment to GAYLE’s lead. While minimal, this arrangement achieves a few key things:

  • The raw, distorted timbre of the guitar along with its pattern establishes the song’s gritty rock vibe.
  • The consistent sixteenth-note rhythm puts the song into motion.
  • The sparseness of the arrangement provides room for the song to build both on a cross-section and like-section basis. Additionally, it creates an intimate vibe that perfectly compliments GAYLE’s subdued/moody delivery of the scathing lyrics. This creates strong prosody, effectively heightening the listener’s emotional connection with the song right from the start.

In the last bar of the section, downlifter and riser sound effects are added to the mix, followed by a brief kick pattern at the end. Together, they create an engaging S.I.A. (section impact accentuator) that bolsters the transition into the ensuing verse; calls attention to the “you can all f-off” lyrical summation; and offsets the more “classic/traditional” guitar-driven rock vibe with a modern pop quality, which sets the tone for the entire song.

Chorus 1 Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Verse 1 (0:17 – 0:49)

Stanza 1

With the guitar from the preceding chorus remaining in effect to provide cross-section continuity, the first stanza of the verse builds the arrangement through the introduction of kick, snare, claps, two basses and an additional electric guitar. Together, they achieve the following:

  • They lock the listener into the fully established sparse, dark and simmering groove, which perfectly complements GAYLE’s continued subdued/moody delivery of the troublesome lyrics.
  • The basses and lower-octave guitar fill out the low-end of the frequency spectrum, while the snare, claps and guitar fill out the mid-range. However, there is still no overt high-frequency information in the mix, leaving room for the song to grow from a frequency standpoint.
  • The modern qualities of the electronic kick and snare balance out the more “traditional” rock guitar, further bolstering the song’s relevancy in today’s mainstream marketplace.

Stanza 2

With the core arrangement of stanza 1 remaining in effect to provide continuity, stanza 2 adds a vintage-sounding synth into the mix. While subtle, the additional color, texture and harmonic support it provides is important in heightening interest in the otherwise instrumentally and vocally repetitive section.

Verse 1 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Pre-Chorus 1 (0:49 – 1:04)

Following the cohesive instrumental arrangement build across the chorus and both stanzas of the verse, the pre-chorus notably changes things up through the density, sound pallet, energy/momentum and frequency contrast it provides. Along with the higher-range delivery of the “I’m over this” lyrics, this shift in instrumental arrangement heightens the listener’s engagement leading toward the chorus, bolstering its impact in the process while providing separation between sections of similar accompaniment and feel.

Bars 1-3

With the guitar-driven chord progression and vintage synth providing cross-section continuity, the following elements are notably changed up in the pre-chorus:

  • The electric guitars are pulled from the mix and replaced with acoustic guitar. This provides the pre-chorus with a comparatively thinner sound along with high-end frequency information that was lacking in the preceding sections. Additionally, the more vibrant strumming pattern serves to further heighten interest and momentum leading toward the chorus while maintaining the familiar chord progression.
  • The piercing snare/clap combination from the verse is replaced with a more subdued filtered clap on beats 2 and 4, reducing the punch of the backbeat.
  • The sub-bass is pulled from the mix, further thinning out the low end of the arrangement.
  • The kick is low-pass filtered and featured at a lower level in the mix, resulting in a more “muffled” timbre that results in less low-end. However, it is now playing a more driving eighth-note pattern, which provides the pre-chorus with a heightened degree of forward motion leading toward the chorus.

Bar 4

In the last bar of the pre-chorus, all the elements are abruptly pulled from the mix. In their place, the downlifter and riser effects that were initially featured in the transition between chorus 1 and verse 1 return, though this time with the riser being more pronounced. Together, they form a highly engaging S.I.A. that calls attention to the first iteration of the song-defining “A-B-C-D-E-F-U” hook while setting up the powerful ensuing chorus for maximum impact.

Pre-Chorus 1 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Chorus 2 (1:04 – 1:20)

Following the thinned-out, acoustic guitar-driven pre-chorus and engagement-heightening S.I.A., the second chorus hits with the densest, most powerful arrangement heard thus far in the song. In addition to providing the listener with an impactful high-energy “payoff,” this instrumental arrangement, along with the newly added sung/shouted gang vocals, provides chorus 2 with a new, angrier emotional context compared to the first time around.

Stanza 1

The chorus hits hard right out of the gate with a prominent kick, crash and synth impact sound effect marking its arrival on beat 1. This is followed by what is essentially a more developed version of the verse arrangement, taking the song’s intensity to a peak in both a familiar and fresh manner.

In terms of the drum/bass groove, while its similar to the verse, there are some notable differences to take note of:

  • The kick is doubled by the hat, which accentuates its attack and enables it to further cut through the mix. In terms of its pattern, it is simpler than the verse, which is warranted to help prevent things from becoming overly busy. It sounds exclusively on beats 1 and 3 save for the “and” of beat 4, where it subtly heightens interest leading into the second stanza while punctuating the definitive “f**k you” lyric.
  • The snare, in contrast to the verse, is fuller and processed with copious reverb, which amplifies its presence and contributes to the chorus’s “big” sound. In addition, a subtle thin snare embellishment is heard on the “and” of beat 2, subtly heightening interest in the otherwise instrumentally repetitive section.
  • In addition to the drum and bass groove, the most notable instrumental changeup compared to the verse is the guitar. Here, in lieu of the palm-muted electric guitar, a distorted guitar playing an alternating two-pitch sixteenth-note pattern is featured. In addition to heightening interest and excitement, the qualities of this guitar provide the song with a more notable alt/indie vibe, reminiscent of the Pixies, for instance.

Stanza 2

The second stanza features essentially the same instrumental arrangement as the first, allowing the listener’s full attention to be on the vocals without distraction. The sole variation is a snare fill in the third bar, which subtly heightens interest.

Chorus 2 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Vocal Break 1 (1:20 – 1:28)

The vocal break post-chorus begins in a similar manner as the preceding chorus, with a kick/crash punctuating its arrival on beat 1. However, this time there isn’t an accompaniment pull/downlifter/riser S.I.A. associated with it, which keeps the listener locked into the high-energy groove without missing a beat.

The balance of the section maintains the chorus’s high-energy arrangement, which provides cross-section continuity and allows the listener’s full attention to be on the two vocal hooks without distraction. However, to subtly heighten interest and take the song’s intensity to its first peak, a driving open hi-hat is added to the mix for the first time along with the reintroduction of the palm muted electric guitar, its octave double, and vintage synth from the verse. Note that the inclusion of these verse elements serves to make the song as a whole more cohesive and familiar as well.

At the end of the vocal break, a one-beat partial accompaniment pull S.I.A. is implemented. While subtle, it achieves a few key things:

  • It provides separation between the energetic vocal break post-chorus 1 and verse 2 arrangements.
  • It bolsters the arrival of the familiar verse 2 groove.
  • It highlights the “f” in the abcdefu hook, followed by the “u” hitting on beat one of the ensuing verse.

Vocal Break 1 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Verse 2 (1:28 – 1:44)

Verse 2 is half the length of verse 1, clocking in at four bars. As is typically the case with non-hip hop hit verses, verse 2 develops off of the first verse while decreasing the density and energy following the chorus and vocal break post-chorus, leaving room for growth in subsequent sections. Together, these qualities serve to heighten interest while maintaining familiarity in the scope of the song.

Bars 1-2

The first half of verse 2 builds on the more developed verse 1, stanza 2 arrangement with the following additions and changeups:

  • The snare now features a notable reverb tail, which was not present in verse 1. This provides verse 2 with a new interest-heightening higher-frequency texture that also contributes to its bigger feel. However, note that the reverb isn’t as pronounced as the preceding chorus and vocal break post-chorus, which contributes to the cross-section contrast.
  • A new closed hi-hat playing a sixteenth-note pattern provides more forward motion along with additional high frequency information.
  • A low-level, saturated and low-pass filtered shaker adds a darker, rustling texture to the back of the mix.

The last beat of bar 2 features the only in-section S.I.A. in the song. Consisting of a full accompaniment pull, this achieves a few key things, including:

  • Creating a jarring/surprise moment midway through the section.
  • Highlighting the “you couldn’t take it” lyric.
  • Preventing the continuous groove from becoming overly redundant while setting up its return in the second stanza.
  • Providing like-section contrast against verse 1, which doesn’t contain an in-section S.I.A.

Bars 3-4

Following the S.I.A., the listener is locked back into the core groove of the first stanza. However, to help subtly heighten both interest and energy, an additional guitar, which is cleaner and more reverberant than the other guitars heard thus far in the song, plays off-beat accents.

Verse 2 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Pre-Chorus 2 (1:44 – 2:00)

In contrast to pre-chorus 1, pre-chorus 2 features a notable changeup in the instrumental arrangement, building off of verse 2 for two bars before returning to more familiar territory with the expected timbral shift that is reminiscent of pre-chorus 1.

Bars 1-2

The first half of the pre-chorus keeps the kick, snare, claps, closed hat, shaker, vintage synth, electric bass and electric guitars from the preceding verse in effect, which provides cross-section continuity. However, it also omits certain elements while reintroducing others, serving to heighten both interest and familiarity in the scope of the song:

  • The acoustic guitar from pre-chorus 1 returns, providing like-section familiarity.
  • A new chorused/filtered electric guitar plays the same melodic pattern as the melodic electric guitar 1 in chorus 2.
  • The sub-bass from the verse is omitted from the mix, subtly reducing the pre-chorus’ bottom-end power.

Bars 3-4

Following a reversed hi hat at the end of bar 2, which subtly heightens interest leading into the second-half of the section, the pre-chorus arrangement notably thins in timbre and features more high frequency information, which is a commonality shared with its first occurrence counterpart and creates additional like-section familiarity. And again, this changeup serves to heighten engagement leading into the ensuing chorus and bolster its impact:

  • The kick shifts to a more muffled timbre and eighth-note pattern, a commonality shared with pre-chorus 1.
  • Claps replace the snare, another commonality shared with pre-chorus 1. However, this time around the claps are unfiltered, which makes them more pronounced in the mix and contributes to the overall higher-energy at this point in the song.
  • The hats and shaker are omitted, the former most notably resulting in less high-end frequency information.
  • The cleaner, reverberant off-beat electric guitar stabs are pulled from the mix.

At the end of the section, downlifter and riser effects are once again employed, creating a familiar S.I.A. leading into chorus 3. However, in contrast to the first time around, here the acoustic guitar remains in the mix, which along with the faster-paced kick provides heightened momentum leading into the chorus while providing subtle, like-S.I.A. variation, which helps to prevent things from becoming too predictable.

Pre-Chorus 2 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Chorus 3 (2:00 – 2:15)
Arrangement Overview

Chorus 3 subtly builds on the dense, high-energy vocal break post-chorus 2 arrangement. It adds additional guitar, electric bass, hats, and the new low-level acoustic piano to the mix, which takes density and energy to a near grand peak.

Chorus 3 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Vocal Break 2 (2:15 – 2:31)
Arrangement Overview

Twice the length of vocal break post-chorus 1, vocal break post-chorus 2 maintains the chorus 3 arrangement to provide cross-section continuity, while adding in the electric guitar accents that had previously been featured in verse 2 and pre-chorus 2. While subtle, its addition creates the densest and most energetic arrangement in the entire song, taking the listener’s excitement to a grand apex.

Vocal Break 2 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance

Chorus 4 (2:31 – 2:47)
Arrangement Overview

Following the highly dense and energetic chorus 3 and ensuing vocal break post-chorus, chorus 4 does a complete 180 by stripping back the arrangement to just the chorused/filtered melodic electric guitar and GAYLE’s comparatively subdued vocals. This changeup bookends the song on a familiar note, putting this guitar pattern front and center to keep things interesting while winding the song down to an acapella conclusion.

Chorus 4 Instrumental Arrangement: At-A-Glance



Harmonic Progressions


abcdefu features one chord progression that is kept interesting through a variety of delivery styles throughout the song.

Progression 1
Progression 1: Variation 1a (Chorus 1, Verse 1 (Stz. 1))

E5 – G#5 – C#5 – A5

Progression 1: Variation 1b (Verse 1 (Stz. 2), Verse 2)

E – G# – C#m – A

Progression 1: Variation 1c (Pre-Choruses)

E – G# – C#m – A

Progression 1: Variation 1d (Chorus 2 and 3, Vocal Breaks)

E – G# – C#m – A

Progression 1: Variation 1e (Chorus 4)

E – G#5 – C#m – A5

Progression Characteristics

abcdefu’s sole chord progression is rooted in the key of E major, following a I – V/vi – vi – IV pattern. This is a slight variation on the highly popular I – V – vi – IV progression heard in an array of pop and rock hits over the years such as Girls Like You (Maroon 5), Cruise (Florida Georgia Line), Demons (Imagine Dragons), The Edge Of Glory (Lady Gaga), and F**kn’ Perfect (P!nk), to name a few.

In abcdefu, the notable use of V/vi instead of the expected V chord subverts listener expectations with a highly engaging non-diatonic chord. As a result, the progression follows a tonic – secondary dominant – tonic – subdominant pattern, creating moments of tension and release due to the unique secondary dominant chord.

Keeping this repetitive chord progression interesting throughout the song are a host of delivery variations, including palm-muted 16th-note distorted electric guitar power chords, vibrantly strummed acoustic guitar, alternating pitch melodies, and a vintage-sounding synth. These varying deliveries combined with the alternating use of power chords and triads keep the engaging harmonic motion interesting while contributing to the evolving nature of the instrumental arrangement.



Vocals


Vocal Production


Lead Vocal Gender

abcdefu features a solo female lead vocal from GAYLE. Generally hovering between one-quarter and one-third of non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits over the past five years, solo female leads have been trading off with solo male leads for top billing up until 2021, when they tied and slightly trailed all-male duet/group vocals.

Lead Vocal Gender in Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2017 – 2021

Lead Vocal Delivery

abcdefu features an exclusively sung lead vocal delivery. Not surprisingly, non-hip hop Hot 100 Top 10 hits that feature exclusively sung lead vocals have by far been the most popular over the past five years and beyond, with 70% of songs in 2021.

Lead Vocal Delivery in Hot 100 Top 10 (Non-Hip Hop Hits): 2017 – 2021

Background Vocals

In addition to the lead, abcdefu features a host of background vocals including harmonies, unison doubles, sung adlibs, and shouted gang vocals.

Effects & Processing

abcdefu features minimal vocal effects and processing, including reverb, delay and autotune, all of which maintain an intimate vibe while adhering to mainstream vocal production standards.

Vocal Delivery Arrangement Overview

Lead: Female (GAYLE): GAYLE’s lead vocal
BGV 1: Female (Unison Double): Background vocal doubles in unison with the lead
BGV 2: Female (Lead Harmony): Background vocal that harmonizes with the lead on different pitches
BGV 3: Female (Lead Gang Vocals): Background vocals that are tracked many times to create a large “crowd” effect
BGV 4: Female (Independent Backgrounds): Background vocals featured independently from the lead
BGV 5: Female (Independent GAYLE): Lead vocals that are independent embellishments

Key

BGV: Background vocals
S: Sung
SH: Shouted
/: Separates stanzas in sections where a certain vocal type occurs in only one stanza

Vocal Production: Section By Section Detail

Key

Header Markings

LEAD: FEMALE: GAYLE’s lead vocal
BGV 1: LEAD UNISON DOUBLE: Lead vocal doubles in unison
BGV 2: LEAD HARM: Background vocal that harmonize with the lead on different pitches
BGV 3: LEAD GANG: Background vocals that are tracked many times to create a large “crowd” effect
BGV 4: IND BGVs: Background vocals featured independently from the lead
BGV 5: IND GAYLE: Lead vocals that are independent embellishments

Vocal Delivery Markings

S: Sung
SH: Shouted
Color-Coded Lyrics: Denotes lyrics sung with harmonies on the lead (green) and independent of the lead (orange). Note that this matches the color-coding of the above vocal arrangement overview table.

Chorus 1

Chorus 1 features a solo vocal from GAYLE save for the addition of gang vocals that punctuate the final two words. Her voice is panned up the middle and is kept on the natural side, devoid of any layering and notable processing save for some moderate reverb and compression that helps her voice to blend in with the sparse guitar-driven accompaniment.

Keeping GAYLE’s vocal on the more natural side was a strategic, well warranted choice. It provides her subdued/moody delivery of the scathing lyrics with an intimate quality, allowing the listener to develop a deeper emotional connection with GAYLE, and the song, right from the start.

However, this all changes at the tail end of the section on the definitive closing lyric, “f**k off.” Delivered by a multi-voiced gang vocal and panned through the stereo field, this vocal shift serves a few key purposes, including heightening the impact of the definitive lyric, foreshadowing the gang vocal that accompanies GAYLE’s lead in choruses 2 and 3, and having the potential to serve as an A.P.M. (audience participation moment) in a live setting.

Verse 1

Verse 1 picks up where chorus 1 left off, continuing with GAYLE’s predominantly solo vocal, albeit with slightly less reverb to bring her natural-sounding voice to the front of the more developed arrangement.

However, to help heighten interest in this long, vocally and instrumentally stagnant section (twice the length of the next longest section), two instances of harmony are added to the mix, as well as two instances of a shouted background vocal, “Yeah.” The first harmony occurs midway through stanza 2, where multiple pitches harmonize with GAYLE on the lyric “what a connection.” However, the lower-level, reverb processing and hard left and right panning across the stereo field keeps GAYLE’s centered lead as the focal point while the background vocal provides a colorful embellishment.

The other background vocal comes at the tail end of the section and is featured independently of GAYLE’s lead. Here we have a simple, multi-layered, sustained “ah” traversing the stereo field at a relatively low level in the mix. In addition to serving as a colorful embellishment leading into the chorus, it also creates familiarity with another recent pop/punk anthem, Olivia Rodrigo’s Good 4 U, which similarly uses the technique throughout the song.

Pre-Chorus 1

Pre-chorus 1 continues with GAYLE’s solo lead, maintaining the intimate quality that has been in effect throughout the preceding chorus and verse. However, here her voice is slightly enhanced due to parallel processing, a production technique that subtly mixes in a brighter, saturated version of her vocals underneath the lead. This provides her higher-register vocal with slightly more presence in the lighter, acoustic-guitar-driven arrangement and helps to call further attention to the chorus set-up lyrics.

Chorus 2

Following three consecutive sections of generally solo, intimate vocals from GAYLE, chorus 2 provides a significant shift with the inclusion of sung lead unison doubles and shouted/sung hybrid gang vocals alongside GAYLE’s lead. However, note that GAYLE’s lead is still the focal point of the section, which provides cross-section continuity.

In addition to bolstering the chorus’ power and ability to stand out along with the denser instrumental arrangement, this vocal changeup also provides the song with heightened emotional dimension. While the first time around the scathing lyrics were delivered in a more intimate and subdued manner, here, after the lyrical developments in the verse and chorus, the more powerful vocals put the familiar lyrics in a well-warranted angrier context.

Vocal Break 1

Vocal break post-chorus 1 follows suit with the preceding chorus, maintaining the same vocal qualities. This both provides cross-section continuity and helps to emphasize the dismissive vocal hooks in the dense mix.

Verse 2

Verse 2, which is half the length of verse 1, features essentially the same vocal qualities as the second stanza of verse 1. This both creates like-section familiarity with its verse 1 counterpart while heightening engagement against the stagnant gang vocal delivery of the preceding chorus and vocal break post-chorus sections.

Pre-Chorus 2

Pre-chorus 2 follows suit with its pre-chorus 1 counterpart save for the addition of the lead-harmonizing vocals. While relatively low in the mix, the multi-pitch harmony provides the pre-chorus with additional color and texture in addition to the more pronounced changeup in accompaniment.

Chorus 3

Chorus 3 features the same vocal qualities as chorus 2, which provides like-section familiarity in the scope of the song. The main differentiation stems from subtle development in the accompaniment and lyrical changeups on lines 3 and 4.

Vocal Break 2

Vocal break post-chorus 2 is twice the length of its first occurrence counterpart and possesses both similarities and differences in the vocal production.

The main commonality between the two sections is GAYLE’s lead, which is paired with the gang vocals. However, to provide subtle like-section variation and further heighten excitement and energy at this point in the song, additional gang vocal layers are added to the mix. Furthermore, an independent GAYLE vocal is featured at the transition point between stanzas, subtly heightening interest while showcasing GAYLE’s vocal chops.

Chorus 4

The fourth and final chorus reverts to the solo vocal that defined chorus 1, which bookends the song on a familiar note. However, there is notably less reverb, which creates the most intimate vocal delivery heard over the sparsest instrumental accompaniment. This provides new emotional dimension at the conclusion of the song, as opposed to the angrier deliveries that defined choruses 2 and 3. Additionally, the exposed nature of the ending further highlights GAYLE’s vocal chops with a unique, acapella melodic changeup.

Vocal Melody


Overview

abcdefu possesses all of the melodic qualities that one might expect to find in a major hit: adherence to the K.I.S.S. ME principle (keep it simple, singable and memorable), making use of highly common A.M.P. melodies (alternating melodic patterns), recycling melodies in both fresh and familiar ways in the vocal break post-chorus, striking an effective balance of repetition and contrast both within and across sections, and perfectly jibing with GAYLE’s vocal delivery to heighten the listener’s emotional connection with the lyrics.

However, the song also features unique qualities that set it apart from many of its mainstream contemporaries. One of the most notable is the chorus’s nursery rhyme-styled melody a la Rain, Rain Go Away, which delivers the scathing lyrics in a taunting manner that creates a sense of irony that the listener may, or may not, be aware of. Another is the atypical variations in bookending choruses, where the “A-B-C-D-E-F-U” hook is omitted the first time around and the melody is altered at the tail-end of the song. However, while atypical, these decisions were made with intent and purpose and serve the song perfectly.

Vocal Melody Graph Key
Y Axis: Pitches
X Axis: Song sections and melodic range
Lines: Depict melodic patterns with each dot representing a particular pitch

KEY

Graphs: Reflect lead vocals (excludes harmony)

Numbers in the Graphs: Depict the scale degree of each note

Curved Line: Slur across two or more pitches

Vocal Melody Part Classifications

Main melodic parts, such as upper-case A, B and C, reflect the main melodic structure of each line in a song section. Sub-melodic parts, such as lower-case a, b and c, reflect melodic structure both within and across lines.

The vocal melody part classifications in each section are specific to that particular section type (i.e. verses, pre-choruses, etc.) and do not relate to other section types. (i.e. part A classification in verse 1 does not relate to part A in the chorus, but part A in verse 1 does relate to part A in verse 2).

Vocal melody parts are determined by pitches, rhythms and melodic pattern commonalities.

VERSES
Overview

Verse 1 spans an octave from G#3 to G#4 and is composed of two highly similar stanzas that follow an AAAB/AAAB main melodic structure. However, there are subtle differences between them that help to keep things interesting without sacrificing connectability and memorability. Verse 2 spans the same range as verse 1 and also follows an AAAB main melodic structure. However, it differs in that it only features one stanza and possesses additional subtle melodic differences.

On a cross-section basis, compared to the preceding choruses, the verses focus more on low register melodies, incorporate a greater degree of monotone deliveries, and have generally longer-length phrases. However, both share the commonality of A.M.P. melodies.

A.M.P.

A.M.P. is an acronym for alternating melodic pattern, where two pitches repeatedly alternate in a stepwise or intervallic manner. In the verse, the A.M.P. is featured subtly in the first three lines of each stanza, and more prominently in the last line. Below is an illustration of verse 1’s use of A.M.P.s, highlighted in red.

Verse 1 A.M.P.s

Melodic Structure Overview

Verse 1 Melodic Direction: At-a-Glance

Verse 2 Melodic Direction: At-a-Glance

Verse 1 Melodic Part Structure: At-a-Glance

Verse 2 Melodic Part Structure: At-a-Glance


*Note the use of primes (i.e., b1′) to illustrate a nearly identical melodic sub part

Melodic Structure Detail

*Note that all images and analysis shown below pertains to verse 1 unless otherwise noted. Differences between verses 1 and 2, if any, are detailed in each line grouping’s analysis.

Stanza 1
Lines 1 & 2